This maybe has been done before

[TheKnightWhoSay...NI!]

whose better?

1.Vintersorg
2.Vortex

 

[yourdeadgroom]

you're gonna get flamed for this


Oh, and Vintersorg, BTW

 

[corrado]

They both rule. Some kind of duet would be cool (or a vocal trio, with Garm joining in...= the 3 Metal tenors, maybe, muahaha)

 

[TheKnightWhoSay...NI!]

you're gonna get flamed for this

why? i didn t say vintersorg is a bad singer, but i prefer vortex majestic voice

 

[Henrik Main]

You're gonna get flamed cause you're starting a thread about something that has been discussed a million times before on this forum

 

[TheKnightWhoSay...NI!]

You're gonna get flamed cause you're starting a thread about something that has been discussed a million times before on this forum

oh ok i didnt know that, i´m quite new

 

[Guttorm]

Vortex.
I think Mr V makes a better musical appearance in Vintersorg, Otyg and Havayoth than in Borknagar.

 

[Loco Bahamut]

actually i perfer Garm over Vintersorg and Vortex

 

[Staffan]

Vintersorg easily... I don't like vortex clean at all

 

[Inner_Landscape]

Vintersorg.

 

[Collapse Generation]

I prefer Vintersorgs' vocals.

 

[oden]

I like them both

 

[svältvinter]

both of them has such a kickass falsesingingvoice live!!

 

[Erik Tiwaz]

both of them has such a kickass falsesingingvoice live!!

Please explain what you mean here...
Do you mean they sing false (like in 'not in tune') or that you like their falsetto's? (not that they use falsetto all that much though)

 

[svältvinter]

Please explain what you mean here...
Do you mean they sing false (like in 'not in tune') or that you like their falsetto's? (not that they use falsetto all that much though)

I love like the things Vintersorg doing on "the black token" on the "from the montains to the shore" part. Maybe one of the things that whould fit into the "most annoyoing moments of vintersorg thread)

And when they´are trying to keep a long high tune like vortex doing on the bigining of the dimmuborgir inferno video (http://www.nrk.no/dynasx?p_lenke_id=211100&p_artikkel_id=1751385&mswmext=.asx)

 

[Astral Poetry]

Vintersorg is better overall.

 

[Zoroaster]

1. Garm
2. Vortex
3. Vintersorg (but I do like Otyg!)

 

[En Vind Av Sorg]

Like i said before, vintersorg i would go with all around. I do like Vortex's clean vocals on the new dimmu album (the only thing i do like about it). And of course his work with Borknagar

 

[DarksomePoet]

I repeat for the 10.000 time
Vortex for the expression on vocals, Vintersorg for the great tecnique on live.
Hail!

 

[winter]

I think they both have great voices but... my vote goes for Vintersorg. Vortex does good job in Dimmu, but like someone said on this forum before money seem to mean more than music for him. Ofcourse i may be wrong but don't you have the same feeling sometimes ? He has to concentrate on one band , but he can't/don't want to write to much there. On new dimmu album he sings just in 2 songs...
Now "Vinty" .
"Genuine Pulse" was first song with Vintersorg on voc i heard ( i have never heard bands like Otyg before ) and ... i was very surprised. I liked it very much! I also think that Vintersorg's harsh voc is better than vortex'