Who wants their voice on DT's new album?
- Thread starter Metalman7983
- Start date
notworthy
anacrucix
aka Shredcaptain Matt
i have like 4 albums and a dvd, the vocals on a couple of tracks from octavarium are alright (these walls, Never enough) but i dont think ill ever come to terms with dream theaters lyrics, pain, oh the pain.
noble savage
Member
Scenes from a memory is hands down my all time favorite cd! I bought it 4 years ago and listen to it atleast once a week. I am showing no sign whatsoever of getting bored with it and I hope I never do!
Matt
Active Member
Lol, that's actually my second favorite song. I like Fatal Tragedy best though.
I think you guys are all way to harsh on dream theater, either you guys call them gods or you spite them... Get the fuck over it, they're a great band who have their ups and downs, they're very talented and know what they're doing, the only thing that I can say makes me listen to them less is some of there stuff gets borring indeed, but I'm a fan of ToT so...
anacrucix
aka Shredcaptain Matt
anacrucix
aka Shredcaptain Matt
Matt
Active Member
anacrucix
aka Shredcaptain Matt
ive never met a person in real life who likes that album i think its just in this dark corner of the internet that people enjoy it
noble savage
Member
anacrucix
aka Shredcaptain Matt
Rose Immortal
Spirit of Hope
- Jun 19, 2004
- 1,425
- 10
- 38
That's basically the same point I'm trying to make. There's really only one album that pisses me off...the rest is fine. They don't have to be perfect for me to like the stuff of theirs that I do like.
Anonymous
L'Étranger
Scenes from a Memory is what started me on DT, I used to think they sucked till I heard it.
Beyond this Life is my favorite tune on the album.
Beyond this Life is my favorite tune on the album.
progmetaldan
Member
I think you're rightthere, and it's the only thing you've been right about this whole discussion...
I can't believe you guys were having this discussion without me!
Firstly, I reckon a big thanks to Joeshabadoo for that report seeing as that it was vry informative and actually on-topic...
Scenes From A Memory is my all time favourite album ever, it was not only the first DT album, but the first progressive album of any kind! I have no problem with long instrumental sections, I happen to enjoy Beyond This Life and Dance Of Eternity and in fact all of the songs on the album apart from the talking at the start... I also love what Jordan Rudess brought to the band, and when you consider that SFAM was the follow up to a really average album in FII, he really helped bring them back up to where they should be.
As with any band there are parts which I love, and parts which I don't really enjoy, but it is the overall product which really counts, and I consider SFAM to be their masterpiece. I love all their albums, but to put them in order would be:
SFAM
IAW
TOT
SDOIT
A
WDADU
O
FII
There you go, to all the DT haters out there- STOP!!!
Kenneth R.
Cináed
progmetaldan
Member
Is what you just did even legal?
Seriously though, that's friggin' awesome.
That's true, if it said no camera's, how'd you take those photos??? Or did you take them afterwards...
@ Kenneth:
Who cares if you're in the credits or not? I would just be happy with being part of the album and meeting the band.
I like all the "wanky" instrumental stuff, if they didn't have that I don't think they would be Dream Theater.
Jordan Rudess is king of all things Keyboard. Ragtime FTW
It's funny how any Dream Theater thread ever almost always turns in to a flame war about whether they're good or not.
Usually between Metal Heads and Prog Snobs too. (Stereotypes, OH NOES)
I like all the "wanky" instrumental stuff, if they didn't have that I don't think they would be Dream Theater.
Jordan Rudess is king of all things Keyboard. Ragtime FTW
It's funny how any Dream Theater thread ever almost always turns in to a flame war about whether they're good or not.
Usually between Metal Heads and Prog Snobs too. (Stereotypes, OH NOES)
