why does jonas suck so much live

[Scourge of Malice]

If you werent at the show, don't bash his opinion. Maybe Jonas had a bad night.

 

[Cerulean]

Maybe
And does that give him the right to bash Jonas? I don't really think so

 

[exy]

Maybe
And does that give him the right to bash Jonas? I don't really think so

For the first time i agree with you.

 

[Sinistas]

He sounded great the other night in NH...

 

[stefan86]

I'd be surprised the time anyone says anything negative about Katatonia without getting bashed here.

 

[Scourge of Malice]

Maybe
And does that give him the right to bash Jonas? I don't really think so

Well if he thought he was bad then he thought he was bad. He's not saying he's a horrible singer all around though.

 

[all_sins_undone]

im not saying jonas is terrible. im quite fond of his lyrics, apart from the nu-metalish shit on viva emptiness. im just saying, jonas couldn't hit the proper notes for shit last night. he also cracked on stage. and thats being generous.

 

[affinityband]

Im being honest phil, i watched the dvd and thought god that sounds bad. But then when i saw them live it restored my faith. Maybe it was just a bad night.

 

[°scarlet°]

im not saying jonas is terrible. im quite fond of his lyrics, apart from the nu-metalish shit on viva emptiness. im just saying, jonas couldn't hit the proper notes for shit last night. he also cracked on stage. and thats being generous.

there are different ways to express an opinion though...
coming to the band's own forum just to state jonas 'suck' sounds to me like a pretentious attempt to attract attention.
that said, it could happen that something goes wrong on a gig, sure, but there are more proper ways to express it, simple as that.
no hard feelings, nothing personal, eh :Smug:

 

[Anthony3]

I just seen them three times over the weekend. Jonas sounded great.

 

[affinityband]

there are different ways to express an opinion though...
coming to the band's own forum just to state jonas 'suck' sounds to me like a pretentious attempt to attract attention.
that said, it could happen that something goes wrong on a gig, sure, but there are more proper ways to express it, simple as that.
no hard feelings, nothing personal, eh :Smug:

Or maybe it could be to see if any of the fans felt the same way on that particular night. Pretty absurd to dicate how one should express an opinion.

 

[all_sins_undone]

there are different ways to express an opinion though...
coming to the band's own forum just to state jonas 'suck' sounds to me like a pretentious attempt to attract attention.
that said, it could happen that something goes wrong on a gig, sure, but there are more proper ways to express it, simple as that.
no hard feelings, nothing personal, eh :Smug:

unless im mistaken, scarlet, isn't the katatonia forum the appropriate place to voice opinions concerning the band? okay, im not a katatonia fan-boy, okay, i didn't sugar coat my original post. so what? jonas' performance was incredibly subpar last night. im going to be honest and say that it even ruined several of the songs. deal with it, hes not perfect

 

[exy]

coming to the band's own forum just to state jonas 'suck' sounds to me like a pretentious attempt to attract attention.

Attempt to attract attention huh?I think its funny to say that.I know its not that right to say "sucks" but accusing someone with "trying to attract attention" is not the perfect expression too.It just shows your desires i hafta admit.I think there is no need to exaggerate.He thinks "jonas sucks"i think "jonas rulez" other one thinks "jonas is ok".Just opinions man..

 

[BlueSky]

apart from the nu-metalish shit on viva emptiness.

it's ok to have you're own opinion so anyone getting all offensive about that should chill but this statement shows you he knows nothing.

clears that one up

 

[Verwuestung]

let me sum up the second page of this thread so far:

bla bla bla bla bla

 

[Cerulean]

And somewhere on this page someone is contraddicting himself compared to a previous post.
Hilarious!

 

[all_sins_undone]

it's ok to have you're own opinion so anyone getting all offensive about that should chill but this statement shows you he knows nothing.

clears that one up

unfortunately for you, worshipping the shitty lyrics on Viva doesnt prove anything about me.

 

[all_sins_undone]

And somewhere on this page someone is contraddicting himself compared to a previous post.
Hilarious!

plz point it out to me, either im missing something or you're just being illogical.

 

[Cerulean]

It's not about you, don't worry

 

[all_sins_undone]

i'm used to getting gangbanged by raging fanboys tbh