No what I mean is, you're going wrong because nothing you listed was Sludge Metal in any sort of real sense of the style.
But if you don't like Eyehategod it's likely not a genre for you haha,
but maybe you might like the much slower side of Sludge Metal, like this:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vYbgg_9YUZs
Or, if you're a fan of Coffins, perhaps check out their Sewage Sludgecore Treatments EP which is all covers of Sludge Metal bands, it's a fucking great gateway into real Sludge.
I don't know how they can be overrated while so many people overlook them. I often encounter people who know they from their name but never listened to any of their tracks.
nah, Neurosis are some of the true master musicians of our time. Putting out 5 undeniable masterpieces isnt easy. Seeing them live was like a spiritual experience. Masters of their craft, no doubt.
i know your modus operandi is to listen and like only a band's debut but Neurosis only got better.
i know your modus operandi is to listen and like only a band's debut