April Ethereal is awesome, it has a really heavy feel. I've never liked the production on MAYH even though I have fallen in love with the album. Imagine how good it would sound if it had the production quality of BWP...
Opeth played When, at the gig in Oslo, september 2005. It was climax! I love April Ethereal too, and just in matter of fact, all tracks on MYAYH are cool! It has no flaws what so ever!
I definately want to hear both MAYH and BwP in their entireties. That would make for one hell of a show if it happened on the same night. Damn think of that, open with Prologue+April Ethereal. Close with Blackwater PArk. ahhh, damn