That kick sound has that Sneap-esque "soggy" attack that I love so much and have finally figured out how to achieve:
1) Andy's tips: wood or plastic beater; batter head tuned as loose as possible without wrinkles. I bought a used 22" birch Pearl Master's Studio for $300 earlier this year, for the sole purpose of learning to capture the metal kick sounds I most enjoy
2) In my case, I used an Audix D6 for the low end; Shure SM91 inside to pick up the attack
3) Low-pass the D6 quite low, until all the woofiness is gone- I think I seriously was down in like the 150Hz range or so (side note- I've noticed that hi-passing and low-passing with any of my Waves EQ plug-ins actually doesn't remove everything beyond your specified frequency, it turns it down more like a very extreme shelf. Not sure if all plug-ins are like this...)
4) Hi-pass the SM91 quite high as well, I believe I was in the 2k-ish range.
At this stage, my immediate reaction upon hearing the two tracks together was "WOW, I'm definitely on the right path"...
5) Find a good level blend of the two tracks, and then bus or print them together.
From here, really sculpt out the low end; it is MANY times easier (although still annoyingly difficult) within in the context of a mix. Low pass the kick as well to remove some of the extreme high end.
6) Next, I was really just playing around with no real course of action in mind, but I smashed the kick with the RComp with a fast attack (as hard as possible before the low end begins to get farty and destroyed, like 15dB of reduction).
Now it sounded nice and punchy and the low end was even more controlled, but needed to be tweaked some more
7) On a whim, after realizing that the sound of the compressor was definitely helping the "soggy" attack sound even better, I threw a C4 on there and bypassed all but the highest band, so I could hit the high end harder without making the low end get farty. With a fast attack, I ended up expanding everything above 2k-ish another +8dB or so, and then turned that band's gain down to match the input level, and... FANTASTIC!
8) More fiddling with EQ to adjust the hi-pass and other weird little tones and frequencies present in the kick sound, and...my kick is sounding frighteningly close to a soggy Andy Sneap kick and I actually like it just as much... (Mind you, the EQ plug-ins are all before the RComp and C4)
Don't get me wrong here- this was not a fast process, and I've spent hours and hours on and off over many months fiddling with the processing on my stupid kick drum, and the info I've just posted here is just kind of the quick run down of the things I've discovered that have definitely sounded good in my case. I'll post something soon here that has the kick in it, or maybe I'll just be super cool and give out the processed (or unprocessed) sample... I think you would all love it.
Just wait, Andy is going to come on here and say "you're really overthinking it, there's just a touch of eq and compression on my kick"
Well guess what, imaginary Andy answer- I don't believe you (yet)
