Battle of the bands

[Allfader]

Sarcofago are first and foremost a thrash metal band before you can start applying/tacking on anything else to their name. So yes, they should be here.


yea i agree but their first album is more thrash than black or death.

If this is about bands and not specific albums, then CF shouldn't be here.

 

[TechnicalBarbarity]

yeah like i said in my earlier post, i agree.

 

[no country for old wainds]

celtic frost is a bit of a can of worms even if we're talking about the early stuff. i mean, what about slaughter and dream death?

 

[HamburgerBoy]

imo Slaughter should be for a death metal competition, but Dream Death are very thrashy, though admittedly I forgot about them in my quest for bands with larger careers. But thinking about it, I decided to boot Vendetta (who I don't even like that much) to add them.

Metallica
Megadeth
Slayer
Anthrax
Kreator
Tankard
Destruction
Sodom
Testament
Sepultura
Razor
Overkill
Vio-lence
Exodus
Voivod
Dark Angel
Nuclear Assault
D.R.I.
Deathrow
Devastation
Rigor Mortis
Coroner
Artillery
Anacrusis
Whiplash
Sacrifice
Morbid Saint
Annihilator
Watchtower
Forbidden
Sadus
Demolition Hammer
Suicidal Tendencies
Heathen
Mekong Delta
Toxik
Realm
Believer
Dream Death
Sarcofago
Vektor
Holy Terror
Holy Moses
Obliveon
Despair
Invocator
Sabbat (Jpn)
Sabbat (UK)
Bulldozer
Necrodeath
Protector
Living Death
Death Angel
Flotsam and Jetsam
Infernal Majesty
Hexenhaus
Carnivore
Onslaught
Stone
Nasty Savage
Exhorder
Disciples of Power
Aspid
Messiah

EDIT: Removed Possessed since people seem to be leaning towards saving them for the death metal competition, and stuck Vendetta back in

EDIT #2: Actually, double-fuck Vendetta, there's no reason to include them over Living Death

 

[TechnicalBarbarity]

yo @jimmy101 are we doing 32 or 65? Wouldn't mind adding another 32 to my list.

 

[jimmy101]

Qualified bands

Dark Angel
Razor
Sepultura
Voivod
Heathen
Coroner
Morbid Saint
Mekong Delta
Overkill
Testament
Exodus
Vio-lence
Nuclear Assault
Anacrusis
Tankard
Megadeth
Slayer
Metallica
Sodom
D.R.I.
Kreator
Watchtower
Deathrow
Demolition Hammer
Despair
Sacred Reich
Annihilator
Forbidden
Sadus
Whiplash
Artillery
Sacrifice
Devastation
Rigor Mortis
Warbringer
Sabbat (UK)
Toxik
Vektor
Protector
Holy Moses
Exhorder
Xentrix
Believer
Exmortus
Exumer
Suicidal Tendencies
Anthrax
Flotsam & Jetsam
Hexenhaus
Death Angel
Necrodeath
Infernal Majesty
Obliveon

53 bands have now qualified

Bands with one nomination

Atrophy
Solstice
Num Skull
Incubus
Slaughter
Holy Terror
Havok
Hatchet
Antidote
Hexen
Black Fast
Violator
Municipal Waste
Target
Midas Touch
Vendetta
Mania
Rage
Sacral Rage
Realm
Dream Death
Invocator
Bulldozer
Living Death
Carnivore
Onslaught
Stone
Nasty Savage
Disciples of Power
Aspid
Messiah
Sabbat (Japan)


Just eight more bands required now.

 

[jimmy101]

yo @jimmy101 are we doing 32 or 65? Wouldn't mind adding another 32 to my list.

Doing 64. Care to second any of the bands that have gotten only one nom?

 

[TechnicalBarbarity]

Doing 64. Care to second any of the bands that have gotten only one nom?

sure, can you give me a little time?

 

[jimmy101]

Also, Sacrofago have received two noms, but don't think they belong in the thrash column.

 

[TechnicalBarbarity]

100% without a doubt they do.

 

[jimmy101]

100% without a doubt they do.

Well if that's the case then they have also made it in.

Everyone agree with this?

 

[TechnicalBarbarity]

Qualified bands

Dark Angel
Razor
Sepultura
Voivod
Heathen
Coroner
Morbid Saint
Mekong Delta
Overkill
Testament
Exodus
Vio-lence
Nuclear Assault
Anacrusis
Tankard
Megadeth
Slayer
Metallica
Sodom
D.R.I.
Kreator
Watchtower
Deathrow
Demolition Hammer
Despair
Sacred Reich
Annihilator
Forbidden
Sadus
Whiplash
Artillery
Sacrifice
Devastation
Rigor Mortis
Warbringer
Sabbat (UK)
Toxik
Vektor
Protector
Holy Moses
Exhorder
Xentrix
Believer
Exmortus
Exumer
Suicidal Tendencies
Anthrax
Flotsam & Jetsam
Hexenhaus
Death Angel
Necrodeath
Infernal Majesty
Obliveon

53 bands have now qualified

Bands with one nomination

Atrophy
Solstice
Num Skull
Incubus
Slaughter
Holy Terror
Havok
Hatchet
Antidote
Hexen
Black Fast
Violator
Municipal Waste
Target
Midas Touch
Vendetta
Mania
Rage
Sacral Rage
Realm
Dream Death
Invocator
Bulldozer
Living Death
Carnivore
Onslaught
Stone
Nasty Savage
Disciples of Power
Aspid
Messiah


Just eight more bands required now.

EDIT: DID WE FORGET ABOUT RIPPING CORPSE OR IS IT JUST ME AGAIN???

EDIT: + RIPPING FUCKING CORPSE

 

[HamburgerBoy]

INRI isn't exactly thrash but the two following are relatively well-acclaimed and definitely thrash.

Minotaur? I made a list up to 128 bands and they weren't even worthy of that.

EDIT: Ripping Corpse is clearly death metal, unless you meant Rotting Corpse.

 

[RadicalThrasher]

Pushing for Num Skull. Just on the strength of Ritually Abused. Fucking killer album, stacked with riffs.

 

[TechnicalBarbarity]

Are you retarded? Ripping Corpse are one of the earliest death/thrash bands(plenty of which are already on here) ya' doofus.

Minotaur? I made a list up to 128 bands and they weren't even worthy of that.

bruh a thrash list from you is worthless to me. btw they shit your beloved kings of 3rd rate thrash, exodus

 

[TechnicalBarbarity]

Pushing for Num Skull. Just on the strength of Ritually Abused. Fucking killer album, stacked with riffs.

ill give Num Skull a vote(i really dig Ritually abused) if you help me push in Ripping Corpse ... another band i know you really dig
??

 

[HamburgerBoy]

Ripping Corpse are one of the earliest death/thrash bands

After Slayer, Kreator, Possessed, Sepultura, Sarcofago, Morbid Angel, Insanity, Pestilence, Infernal Majesty, Poison, Pentagram, Necrodeath, and other bands I'm forgetting, yeah, good point. derp

 

[HamburgerBoy]

Like lmao, I'm relistening to their Death Warmed Over demo and this is about as pure thrash as you can get.

 

[RadicalThrasher]

ill give Num Skull a vote(i really dig Ritually abused) if you help me push in Ripping Corpse ... another band i know you really dig
??

List edited

 

[TechnicalBarbarity]

After Slayer, Kreator, Possessed, Sepultura, Sarcofago, Morbid Angel, Insanity, Pestilence, Infernal Majesty, Poison, Pentagram, Necrodeath, and other bands I'm forgetting, yeah, good point. derp

1987 makes them one of the earliest death/thrash bands. Is that somehtng we're going to argue about? Dreaming With the Dead is a bonfide death/thrash classic. How about we concentrate on the part that you think they actually dont belong here because they're not thrash?