Best Floyd?

[Ken Lyall]

i have plenty of modesty. around those who humble me.

 

[Don Corleone]

i thought it was a universally accepted law that dark side of the moon is the best album ever by any band.

 

[vampyré]

Patterson

 

[Tubbs]

I don't really like Dark Side too much... it's great, but I think Pink Floyd has a few albums that are better. For example, the ones I put on my list.

 

[arzachel]

meddle

+1, with animals coming in a close second.

 

[FRUGiHOYi]

dark side, duh

 

[Ken Lyall]

I don't really like Dark Side too much... it's great, but I think Pink Floyd has a few albums that are better. For example, the ones I put on my list.

no offence, but have you really heard Floyd? from the start.

 

[Lost_Orchid]

Dark Side of the Moon, Wish You Were Here, and Animals. Can't really choose a favorite out of the three.

 

[Tubbs]

no offence, but have you really heard Floyd? from the start.

Uhh... no. That's why I have every one of their albums from Piper At The Gates of Dawn to the Division Bell.

Nope, definitely don't listen to them almost every day.

Definitely haven't tried learning any of their songs.

Certainly haven't read their entire biography.

*obvious sarcasm

 

[Ken Lyall]

Uhh... no. That's why I have every one of their albums from Piper At The Gates of Dawn to the Division Bell.

Nope, definitely don't listen to them almost every day.

Definitely haven't tried learning any of their songs.

Certainly haven't read their entire biography.

*obvious sarcasm

ok mr 16 year old, you have a good influence and understanding of floyd. Good for you.

 

[Lord Byron]

I love Animals and the Division Bell. Both amazing albums. Not too gone on the earlier stuff. It just sounds kind of childish but i guess a lot of that has to do with the fact that syd was the head honcho at the time. After that they started to get better with each passing album. With the exception of The Final Cut....thats just bollocksuke: uke:

 

[Stimuli]

All this talk about meddle and noone mentions "A Pillow of Winds"...

for shame...

I consider all Floyd from 1970 to 1979 pretty much equal...

If I were to chose a fav. for the moment... I would say Animals...

 

[NFU]

ok mr 16 year old, you have a good influence and understanding of floyd. Good for you.

at 16 i knew every floyd/rush/yes/beatles/zep/sabbath album backwards and forwards. i wouldnt assume he isnt familiar just because of age.

 

[Ken Lyall]

With the exception of The Final Cut....thats just bollocksuke: uke:

can't agree more, i cannot even listen to it. Sheer bollocks.

 

[Ken Lyall]

at 16 i knew every floyd/rush/yes/beatles/zep/sabbath album backwards and forwards. i wouldnt assume he isnt familiar just because of age.

yea, good for him, maybe I am just jealous, I matured late

 

[Tubbs]

at 16 i knew every floyd/rush/yes/beatles/zep/sabbath album backwards and forwards. i wouldnt assume he isnt familiar just because of age.

Yeah... my 3 brothers have really gotten me into many kinds of rock and metal.

(I've heard every one of Rush's albums, too.)

 

[Lord Byron]

yea, good for him, maybe I am just jealous, I matured late

Me too. I only got into the Floyd and Opeth three years ago. Got into both of them within 2 or 3 months of each other. Now that was class!!!

 

[Ken Lyall]

(I've heard every one of Rush's albums, too.)

woooooooooo hooooooooo, no seriously, well done

 

[Tubbs]

Well, sorry if I like Rush slightly more than Pink Floyd, jeez.

Keyword: Slightly

 

[Kenneth R.]

i thought it was a universally accepted law that dark side of the moon is the best album ever by any band.

laws have exceptions