Controversial opinions on metal

[AchrisK]

S/T is half filler. Killers, on the other hand, is damn near a masterpiece. ...

I agree about Killers, but not the S/T. I have always found Running Free a bit boring and rock and rolly, and Sanctuary was also never a favorite. Otherwise the Self Titled is amazing, as is Killers. I just watched a movie called Iron Maiden and the NWOBHM. Most of the people interviewed put the S/T superior to Killers, and said Killers lacked something. I disagree.

The band did well with Bruce, and I am not sure what another DiAnno album would have sounded like. I am just glad for the first two.

 

[soulslither]

Just change your avatar because people wont shut up about glam every time you post otherwise.

It really only serves to amuse myself if someone posts something like,"dude you're a fuckin' fag,you like Poison,hahaha"! I often feel the need to be light hearted on these types of boards to offset the hardcore metal guys who take themselves way to seriously.

 

[waif]

There is now an Opeth thread. Let there be no more mention of them.

Killers did not have the magic of Iron Maiden.

 

[The Ozzman]

OPETH

 

[Morbid Death]

OPETH

.

 

[Blind Guardian]

Why? It's not like those two songs are the epitome of good music or even remotely original and unique. That's a stupid thing to say about two incredibly standard acoustic songs that offer very little, if anything, that you can't hear anywhere else.

They're fucking awesome. That they're not unique isn't very relevant or much of a secret. That's some top notch singer/songwriter material in the same level as Nick Drake or Leonard Cohen.

 

[Omni]

It sounds more like they're trying hard to be those guys than reaching the same level as them. This especially applies to Nick Drake and Mikael's sudden infatuation with trying to sing like him. The lyrics also pale in comparison to the works of Drake and Cohen.

 

[Orion Crystal Ice]

They are very good songs.

BWP wouldn't have sucked so much if they weren't just bonus tracks.

 

[Xorv]

Morningrise > anything else

 

[GameFreac]

Top 5 discussions that have been discussed too much and need to end in this thread:

1. Opeth
2. Morbid Angel
3. Darkthrone
4. Slayer
5. Metallica

It will never end

 

[Omni]

I like how you said "top 3" and then included 4. Metallica is also notably absent.

 

[GameFreac]

I like how you said "top 3" and then included 4. Metallica is also notably absent.

Lol...I just remembered Darkthrone as I was posting it...forgot Metallica too

 

[Lateralus14]

lol you don't think Iron Maiden's been discussed too much?

 

[Orion Crystal Ice]

MAIDNE!!!11

 

[The Ozzman]

PREIST!!!!1Pone

 

[GameFreac]

Those were just off the top of my head

 

[Orion Crystal Ice]

best Priest vocalist? definitely Halford.

 

[no country for old wainds]

death needs adding to that list as well, christ

 

[S<issors]

I'd toss Ildjarn on their too, personally. Neither he nor Death is anywhere near Opeth/Slayer/Metallica level, but both conversations crop up a fair amount and always go the exact same way

 

[soulslither]

How can any band be disscused too much in a thread thats titled "Controversial Opinions on metal"? It's not like someone's here talking about Micheal Bolton or some shit! If it's a metal band we're talking about who the fuck gives a shit how much you talk about them? Isn't that the porpose of a thread like this?