Game: ultimate non-metal band

[Rincewind]

53 - Nick Cave (-2)
114 - Tool (+2)

 

[marduk1507]

new Tool sucks, btw.

Hmm, Ive heard it only once and yes, I was kind of disappointed, but this usually happens will all my top fav bands on the first listen. The more I listen to them, the more I love them. I really like Nick, too, but his music doesnt come close to what Aenima and Lateralus mean to me (but his older shit around Tender Prey, Henrys Dream is awesome).

 

[Ethereal Sage]

55 - Nick Cave (+2)
112 - Tool (-2)

 

[incendo]

53 - Nick Cave (-2)
114 - Tool (+2)

 

[QRV]

55 - Nick Cave (+2)
112 - Tool (-2)

 

[Zack]

53 - Nick Cave (-2)
114 - Tool (+2)

 

[QRV]

Hmm, Ive heard it only once and yes, I was kind of disappointed, but this usually happens will all my top fav bands on the first listen. The more I listen to them, the more I love them. I really like Nick, too, but his music doesnt come close to what Aenima and Lateralus mean to me (but his older shit around Tender Prey, Henrys Dream is awesome).

Well, I didn't really think it a bad album, just unremarkable. It's ok, but nothing unheard of, nor as finely produced and elaborated as Aenima or Lateralus. And it's way too long and rather boring after a few songs. Meh.

But I agree, Aenima is a fucking masterpiece and Lateralus is also great. Overall I like Cave better, though.

 

[marduk1507]

51 - Nick Cave (-2)
116 - Tool (+2)

 

[Ethereal Sage]

53 - Nick Cave (+2)
114 - Tool (-2)

 

[La Rocque]

^&^^ exercise in futility

 

[marduk1507]

Like most of your posts.

 

[QRV]

55 - Nick Cave (+2)
112 - Tool (-2)

 

[marduk1507]

53 - Nick Cave (-2)
114 - Tool (+2)

 

[Rincewind]

51 - Nick Cave (-2)
116 - Tool (+2)

 

[incendo]

49 - Nick Cave (-2)
118 - Tool (+2)

 

[QRV]

51 - Nick Cave (+2)
116 - Tool (-2)

 

[QRV]

53 - Nick Cave (+2)
114 - Tool (-2)

 

[incendo]

51 - Nick Cave (-2)
116 - Tool (+2)

 

[Zack]

49 - Nick Cave (-2)
118 - Tool (+2)

 

[Rincewind]

47 - Nick Cave (-2)
120 - Tool (+2)