GMD Votes series question

[The Ozzman]

Would anyone be interested if I decided to redo the Trad/Doom thread into separate threads? Seems some people would have preferred that system.

IE: Instead of Top Trad&Doom albums in one thread we have a top Trad thread and top Doom thread

Just let me know your thoughts please.

 

[rms]

No, the thread title is misleading anyways. It means no posers, so the cool people who left and come back randomly, like Rumpole, can drop 1 band and leave again

 

[The Ozzman]

If it's misleading what should it be?

 

[Baroque]

I'd be interested in seeing the top Doom thread. Although, you could break it further into subgenres of Doom also. How do you compare 2 bands like Trouble and Electric Wizard?

 

[The Ozzman]

I would do a general doom thread which would exclude death/doom because I allowed that in the death metal one..

 

[ClichéUserName]

I'd suggest separating the Doom threads between Trad/Epic/Proto and Extreme (Funeral, Death, Blackened, Drone etc.). Sludge/Stoner should be it's own thing too imo.

Just my 2 cents.

 

[Master_Yoda77]

I think Traditional Doom as one genre (because it's da best) and then Extreme for the other would be fine, but I was pretty happy with how that top 10 turned out.

 

[The Ozzman]

I'd suggest separating the Doom threads between Trad/Epic/Proto and Extreme (Funeral, Death, Blackened, Drone etc.). Sludge/Stoner should be it's own thing too imo.

Just my 2 cents.

Too much work. Doom would be lumped into one for all except death/doom.

I think Traditional Doom as one genre (because it's da best) and then Extreme for the other would be fine, but I was pretty happy with how that top 10 turned out.

Extreme Doom?

 

[Omni]

You know, extreme metal that falls into the category of doom. There's a lot of it, but it can't really be compared to traditional doom metal.

 

[The Ozzman]

You know, extreme metal that falls into the category of doom. There's a lot of it, but it can't really be compared to traditional doom metal.

That's what I thought he meant. I don't like doom metal enough to do two separate threads for it, but if that's what people want then I'll do it.

I think people lost interest in this anyway. Maybe if I come back around to it in a year it'll be fresh again

 

[no country for old wainds]

yeah i wouldn't bother at this point