I can't wait for this. The tracks with Christine sound insane and that Ihsahn bit was just... fuck.
I always hear a lot of repeated licks with Jeff, to be honest. Did nobody notice that the descending lick in Escape Velocity is just a tapped version of the one in Enemies of Reality?
I can't think of a single virtuoso guitarist that's been around for over two decades that has that instantly recognizable feel/sound to their playing that don't have many repeated licks in their playing.
You know it's Paul Gilbert, Zakk Wylde or Yngwie Malmsteen by certain alt picking patterns they play and by their pick attack; you know it's Joe Satriani with that style of legato patterns, you know it's Steve Vai with certain tapping licks.
I had never heard anything else Chris Poland did from Peace Sells...But Who's Buying in 1986 until the OHM album in 2005, Amino Acid Flashback, and the phrasing, melodic choices, vibrato and all that stuff was unmistakably Chris Poland even though it was 19 years apart.
It's those kinda things that gives a player their unique identity and let's you know it's them.
When you have your own unique sound, your own DNA on the playing, you're going to come back to licks that you are apart of your style and who you are and after 20+ years of playing, it's not easy to come up with something entirely new and fresh. And that's okay, because if the feel and phrasing is there, we can probably appreciate it.
Jeff Loomis, while no doubt making the influence that Marty Friedman and Jason Becker/Cacophony had on him quite apparent, still has a style all of his own, something that 99% of other metal guitarists simply don't have.
A lot cooler than most guitar solos in metal that are completely devoid of any interesting phrasing, just putting it on the neck pickup, giving it a compressed as fuck sound and basically just going on autopilot with some 5 string sweeps that sound entirely indistinguishable from the lead guitarist in the band across from them.
Honestly, pretty disappointed. Nothing in that video caught my ear as being really interesting, I felt like I had heard it all before...although I thought the Ihsahn one was pretty cool. And yeah I literally rolled my eyes at the Sibylline Origin thing. I think if you're going to have a "guitar record" which this seems to be...your playing is going to have to be a lot more expressive and meaningful and a lot less sterile/pattern based shredding. To quote one of my friends, "it's like sifting through a bunch of jerking off to find limited moments of actual sex"
EDIT: And there is definitely a double standard here, but coming from the guy who put out This Godless Endeavor I definitely expect better.
I can understand you don't dig it, but the guy has 10000 times more balls and attitude to his lead playing than most metal guitarists today and you absolutely cannot deny that regardless of whether the solos 'speak to you' or not.
That pick attack, the way he just aggressively pushes and pulls the strings with his bends and vibrato, it sounds like he's giving it all his got, he can play slow passes with amazing phrasing that shits all over so called 'feel' guitarists and he can do the 'patterns' as well, whereas seemingly most of today's metal guitarists, all they have is the sterile 'patterns.
They never bothered to learn (or, well, they learned from Kirk Hammett it seems) to do vibrato and bends properly, have no concept of varying the pick dynamics and aren't interested in sometimes using carefully phrased slow passages.
Loomis is in the top 1% of lead playing in metal.