Well, it got an interesting result, but i think this would not work at all.
When the signal goes to the amp it will get different.
I think that the match eq is a good way to learn something about mixes, or 'sounds', but i don't think it will give a magic formula or a perfect balenced mix at all, neither a perfect sound.
There are plenty other elements involved, including the artistic feeling of the entire process, playing, dynamics, etc.
As told here before, i agree with the opinion that matching eq is mimic.
The FUN part (and most painfull too) is to learn how to make good things on your own. Create your own guitar/kick/any instrument sound.