shinderhizzle84
Member
- Dec 3, 2008
- 119
- 0
- 16
I couldn't disagree more. Devastatingly sad music is the most extreme music in my opinion. I think slam / brutal death metal is the only thing that rivals it in terms of extremity. The depressive / suicidal black metal sub-genre is a testament to this. Bands like Abyssic Hate, Forgotten Tomb, and Xasthur. Funeral doom also has more than its fair share of despondent bands, like Nortt, Funeral, and Abyssmal Sorrow. If you don't think DSBM and funeral doom are extreme forms of music then I don't know what to tell you.
I think that any doom metal can't be described by the word 'extreme'. To me, at least, extreme is usually incredibly technical, incredibly fast, and incredibly heavy. Sad, depressive music doesn't usually lend itself to speed and heaviness. Don't get me wrong, I enjoy sad stuff as much as I do the brutal stuff, and the black metal genre is definitely full of it, but the most emotionally-stirring sad music is going to be slow and melodic, and not 'extreme'.
I'm not trying to shit on anyone's tastes here, but you can give me a black metal song and then show me a song like "Limbs" by Agalloch or At the Gates of Sleep by Insomnium and I think it'd be hard to beat songs like that in terms of being full of emotions such as sorrow and anguish and all that good stuff.