Misanthrope said:
Here is my take on it: She was never married to neither girl
i share your views on this. i've seen lost highway five or six times already, and many details - while still not exactly adding up - seem to converge towards that idea. i find especially revealing (although of course i'm not sure revealing
of what ) the scene where pete enters the (hotel?) room upstairs in andy's mansion and alice/renee is inside and says "did you want to talk to me? did you want to ask [falsetto]
whyyy? ?"
it's still ambiguous in its possible reference to fred being jealous and losing his temper when (maybe) in the first place he just wanted to be given an explanation, but i'm not so sure that there actually
was a murder. my take is that there are just fragments of reality in a general situation of delirium, and i also tend to think that pete is the real guy, not fred. when fred is in jail and he gets seizures, we see a close-up of a human brain that i interpret as the real person's mind resurfacing from its fantasy. the cabin in the desert un-exploding also gives me the impression we are "going back" to a different time and space, to something that has already happened.
the timeline is, obviously, absolutely circular. i don't really think this is supposed to make any
narrative sense. at the beginning and at the end of the movie there are two situations of what is without a doubt some severe paranoia: the tapes fred receives document something which is highly suspicious, but there never is any explanation as to what it should be suspicious
of (we don't see renee cheating on him. we don't really see her doing anything bad or mean or wrong). likewise, at the end alice
does not technically betray pete in any form or way.
i also entertained for a while the rather original idea that the whole movie was, in fact,
about dick laurent, which either proves that i'd cling to absolutely anything in order to have it make some sort of perverted sense, or that it's an absolutely awesome film, open to a variety of complicated psychological interpretations.