The Black Dahlia Murder - I really liked these, pretty much hit the nail on the head.
Right. They have three albums out and the Faceless have one, so that's 4 for you.
Behemoth - I quite like these, not to fond of the vocals but I could grow to like it.
Okay, Demigod and The Apostasy are excellent albums. Their older stuff is great but in a different style, more black metal.
Slaves Shall Serve (From Demigod)
Be Without Fear (From The Apostasy)
In Flames - Quite like these
Okay, that's Whoracle. It has his deepest vocal performance, the other albums with Anders are more raspy and the last four are generally alternating singing and screaming. I would recommend Whoracle, Colony, Clayman, and The Jester Race, though.
Artifacts of the Black Rain (from The Jester Race)
Embody The Invisible (From Colony)
Only For The Weak (From Clayman)
Dark Tranquility - I really like the guitars, I can grow to like the vocals.
Sweet. That's my favorite album tbh. The Gallery is great. Also you could try their later stuff, like Fiction.
[ame]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GAhxcgfGmUs&feature=related[/ame]
Nothing To No One (From Fiction)
And if you like that try Soilwork (who are more growly)
Nerve (From Stabbing The Drama)
That's the only album I have from them, word is their other stuff is better...
Nile - Nice guitars but I don't really like the vocals.
Too deep? I think both guitarists alternate vocals and the other guy isn't as deep. Challenge your ears, man. It's good stuff.
Amon Amarth - A friend let me borrow one of their CDs and it took me a while to like it, but eventually I did.
Werd. Which album, btw?
This is Death In Fire, from Versus the World. Live footage from the bonus dvd to their latest Twilight of the Thunder God. Sounds better than on album. Only thing is Johan doesn't sing the last line of each verse. But the tapping part is immensely fucking epic.
Vital Remains - Don't like them all that much, just seems a bit hectic.
Too bad. You did get to the sweeping part, though, right? It's about 2:30 in. If you didn't, do so. Trust me, it's worth it.
The reason I don't like Athiest is because they sound a bit unstructured, a tad random. Maybe it's just the song you gave me.
That's the sort of thing you have to listen to a lot before you really get it. I always give prog metal albums a couple spins before trying to form an opinion. Lets the material sink in, you know?
I guess that I like, well structured, polished stuff with great guitar playing.
I mean, but VR qualify for that. You seem to demand a really clean production as well. My guess is that will pass. But there's plenty of good stuff out there that's well produced.
The Faceless is far better than the BDM.
The Black Dahlia Murder write well-composed, interesting songs. The Faceless blatantly rip off the Black Dahlia Murder, and yet still all their songs wind up as mish-mashes of wankery, breakdowns, and TBDM worship that gets really irritating. Pestilence is an amazing song, but it's the only one I listen to.