"driving a stylistic cleft between the more conservative and the more open-minded listeners."
"ok"
That assertion doesn't imply any quality values, and there's no denying that the conservative fans wanted things to stay the same (stylistically) and more open-minded ones didn't have a problem with Opeth going in a new direction (style). Whether they pulled it off is another thing entirely.
how did you even get in here? you searching for anyone who posts your name in UM?
It's not "open-mind" thing, but fanboy thing.
Even if Mike created a music from farting, toilet, singing of the birds with rap and dubstep elements it would be fantastic because 'OMG MIKE IS GENIOUS I WANT HIM TO HAVE MY KIDS ZOMGZOMGZOMGOMGJOPDAHOIASFSDFASFASDF"