Rate all Opeth albums 1-10

[Sad Madrigal]

Damnation deserves a true 10. Although it is different, it is so beautiful and emotional.
I've found that I am enjoying GR more than Deliverance and Watershed.

 

[Slaydon]

Here is my renewed rating:
Orchid-1
Morningrise-6
MAYH-4
Still Life-10
Blackwater Park-9
Deliverance-6
Damnation-9
Ghost Reveries-8
Watershed-9

Oops, it looks like I offended the Orchid fans!

 

[schism09]

Orchid - 8
Morningrise 10
MAYH 9
Still Life 6
Blackwaterpark 7.5
Deliverance 8.5
Damnation 8.5
Ghost Reveries 8.5
Watershed 8.5

 

[L0bster]

It's a bit hard. Are the grades in comparision with music released in general? Or music released in the same time? Or just in comparasion with their own stuff? I'm gonna have to go for somethin somewhat global I guess.

Orchid - 8
Morningrise - 7
MAYH - 9
Still Life - 10
BWP - 9
Deliverance - 10 (yes, wanna fäd' 'bout it?)
Damnation - 7
Ghost Reveries - 8
Watershed - 8

 

[in_my_time_of_disease]

Christ...ok.
O- 8
MR- 8.5
MAYH- 10
SL- 10
BWP- 10
D1- 9.5
D2- 9
GR- 8
WS- 8.5

 

[Instinct Decay]

Orchid - 5 (Average rating, only because I admit that I haven't heard it altogether. Subject to change.)
Morningrise - 7.5
My Arms, Your Hearse - 8.5
Still Life - 10
BWP - 9.5
Deliverance - 8.5
Damnation - 10
Ghost Reveries - 8
Watershed - 9

 

[^Opethist^]

orchid - 8
morningrise - 8
my arms your hearse - 8.5
still life - 11
blackwater park - 10
deliverance - 9
damnation - 8
ghost reveries - 7
watershed -7

 

[Darkness Of Christ]

Orchid - 6
Morningrise - 9
My Arms, Your Hearse - 8 & 1/2
Still Life - 10
Blackwater Park - 10
Deliverance - 10
Damnation - 10
Ghost Reveries - 8
Watershed - 7 & 1/2

 

[Yaow!]

Orchid - 8
Morningrise - 7
My Arms, Your Hearse - 6
Still Life - 10
Blackwater Park - 10
Deliverance - 8
Damnation - 9 (was surprised by how much i loved this record)
Ghost Reveries - 8.5
Watershed - 8.5

 

[Koi]

I love when people put huge gaps between the quality of opeth albums, like "still life 9.5 and GR 1" just to make their point clear and feel special.

 

[Koi]

i'm super bored now so i will contribute

orchid-5
morningrise-6
MAYH-8
SL-10
BWP-10
Deliverance-9
Damnation-10
GR-9
Watershed-9

 

[Francisco.]

Orchid - 7
Morningrise - 7
MAYH - 9
SL - 10
BWP - 10
Deliverance - 8
Damnation - 9
GR - 8
Watershed - 10