bball_1523
Member
SyXified said:I think a lot of the reason people compare Dream Theater and Symphony X is the instrumental virtuosity and complexity of arrangement that goes into both their writing styles. It's natural to compare Pagannini and Chopin, even though they played different instruments in different styles because both were pushing the boundaries of virtuosity in their fields. With songs like Death of Balance and Dance of Eternity, there is definitly a natural comparison to be made on musicianship, and that means, of course, that there is going to be evaluation of who is superior. So even though they are different genre's and a lot of their sound is different, the two are going to be compared and compared in a competitive manner. I don't think people feel like the members of Symphony X feel the need to compete with DT or that they don't like them, but the "who's better" debates with the fans is only natural for bands with such a strong emphasis on song writing complexity and instrumental prowess
it's natural, but sometimes when someone blurts out Petrucci owns romeo, that's where they cross the line when they don't state their opinions in the most polite way. And that is where everyone starts arguing who is better.
I think it is how the opinion is stated as fact that causes these confrontations.