I love em still. I love all their albums.
But.
They were really never that great to begin with. Just average.
Lars is a bad drummer. Kirk is uninspired. James voice is crap live. Only the bassists kicked ass.
But their songs are good, from any era. Taking them all as metal, well no, Load and Reload aren't good, but as music, as rock, they are nice.
Except for Cure and Fuel. They suck.