Nope, this time you're wrong. Anthony was the worst by a long way. He ruined Fever, and that's a hard song to wreck, and I didn't rate his second song in the least. He's not a big band/swing singer at *all*.
Casey's first song was great, her second was merely good, but she's got the voice for that sort of thing.
Hayley's first song was passable but boring, but she absolutely *nailed* Nature Boy. Suprised the hell out me, she did. If Courtney hadn't sung his last song, Hayley's Nature Boy would have been performance of the night. It was the first time she didn't make me change the channel.
Overall Courtney was the best because he had two really solid performances, and the last one almost deserved his touchdown.
I would have loved to hear Chanel doing Fever. That would have rocked the hizzle.