The greatest of alltime? Your disrespecting many guys that incl. Montana, Young, Aikman, Bradshaw, Staubach, Elway- that I would have the respect to at least wait until comparing Brady to. You already have Manning over them?
STOP YOUR FOOLISHNESS NOW!
Even including this years Pats offense, Peyton has had the better offensive weapons throughout his career and yet Brady has done more with what he has had. Forget the records, even them Brady is closing in on. Give me the "clutch performances" and titles ala Montana, Elway, Young and yes Brady any day.
I'm not disrespecting anyone. Problem is, none of those other QBs have done what Peyton has done and will do by the time he retires. The only difference is that those other QBs you named were on some of the best
TEAMS OF ALL TIME. Meaning alot of those teams could have any above average QB fill in and been just fine. Bradshaw for one comes to mine. He never was that great imo.
I don't understand why you want to use the fact that the Patriots weren't willing to keep their good receivers and pay them the money they deserved against him. So what he's had better receivers than Brady? Even when Brady had arguably the best receiving corps this year, broke all of these offensive records, and went 18-0, it was all for nothing. They fucking lost in the Super Bowl. The best offense to ever show up on the field was fucking shut down. All this bullshit talk about how Brady is better, the Pats never had the receivers that Manning had is just bullshit. THEY HAD THE FUCKING RECEIVERS THIS YEAR AND LOOK WHAT HAPPENED! Mr. Clutch didn't bring the Lombardi trophy home the one time he actually had good receivers. It's about time to you came up with a new argument.
Let me show you why I think Peyton will be the best QB ever:
1. Infinite amount of records? Check.
2. Invented a completely unique style of QB play (like all of the rest of the greats)? Check.
3. Won a championship? Check.
Seems like a winner to me. Since we are arguing whether who is better, let's try this one on for size. Does Brady call his own plays? And I don't just me audibles to run plays or receiver quick hits. I mean, go up to the line of scrimmage. Survey the field, decipher what you see, make sense of what play would be best to run, and actually complete said play? Nah, I don't fucking think so. Brady is like every other QB in the fact that he is just a robot out there. Doing what he is told, when he is told.
One thing that bothers the shit out of me is this whole argument about how "clutch" someone is. Excuse me for liking the idea that the team I root for doesn't have to play like shit on offense for 59 minutes of a game to finally start doing what they are paid to do to finally win the game. But when it comes to Brady, it doesn't even count. 90% of the time he relied on Vinatieri to kick a field goal because he couldn't punch it into the endzone. Lets not forget last year in the AFCCG, with 1 minute left in the game, "Mr. Clutch" was given an opportunity to do what he is said to do better than any QB in the league, or in NFL history, laid the second biggest turd in his career by throwing an interception. Wow, that was pretty clutch of him. I'm not going to even get into this years Super Bowl. I just found it hilarious that their season ended the way it began as well as how he set all of his "records." Throwing prayers to Moss and letting him do all the work.
