First off, a big thanks to JeffTD for making this possible. He included just about all the information here to get us started - I'm merely the 'bookie'.
This essentially lists a number of popular records with their reputed rhythm guitar gear lists. Some of them may be incomplete, but this is all of the information we could put together for the time being, as accurately as we could.
You all are welcome to add your own entries to the thread, which may be picked up and tacked on to the OP here. Enjoy.
36 Crazyfists - Rest Inside the Flames
Pickup: Dunacan/Ibanez
Boost: Maxon OD820
Amp: Krank Rev 1
Cab: Mesa Oversized 4x12
Mic: SM57
As I Lay Dying - An Ocean Between Us
Pickup: EMG 85
Boost: Maxon OD820
Amp: Randall Ultra XL Module
As I Lay Dying - Shadows are Security
Pickup: Gibson passives from older Les Paul
Boost: Maxon OD820
Amp: Krank Revolution 1
Mic: Single SM57
Arch Enemy - Anthems of Rebellion
Pickup: Seymour Duncan JB
Boost: Maxon OD820
Amp: Peavey 5150 and XXX
Cab: Marshall 1960AV with V30s
Arch Enemy - Doomsday Machine
Boost: Maxon OD820
Pickup: Seymour Duncan JB
Amp: Krank Revolution 1 and Mesa Dual Racktifier
Cab: Mesa Oversized 4x12
Mic: Single SM57
Between The Buried and Me - The Silent Circus & Self-Titled
Pickups: EMG 85/81
Guitar: Ibanez S520WNF
Amp: Mesa/Boogie dual rectifier rackmount two-channel head
Cab: Mesa Standard Recto 4x12
Between The Buried and Me - Alaska
Pickups - EMG 85/81
Boost - Ibanez TS808
Guitar - Ibanez S1625TKS
Amp - Mesa/Boogie dual rectifier rackmount two-channel head
Cab - Mesa Standard Recto 4x12
Between The Buried and Me - Colors
Pickups - Dimarzio D-Activators
Boost - Ibanez TS808
Effects - Ibanez WD7 Weeping Demon
Guitar - Ibanez S2170FB
Amp - Mesa/Boogie dual rectifier rackmount two-channel head
Cab - Mesa Standard Recto 4x12
Between The Buried and Me - Colors Live
Pickups - Dimarzio D-Activators
Boost - Ibanez TS808
Effects - Ibanez WD7 Weeping Demon
Guitar - PRS Custom 24
Amp - Mesa/Boogie dual rectifier rackmount two-channel head
Cab - Mesa Standard Recto 4x12
Between The Buried and Me - The Great Misdirect
Pickups - Dimarzio D-Activators
Boost - Ibanez TS808
Guitar - PRS Custom 24
Amp - Mesa/Boogie dual rectifier rackmount two-channel head
Cab - Mesa Standard Recto 4x12
Bloodbath - Nightmares Made Flesh
Boost: Boss HM-2
Amp: Marshall DSL50
Cab: Marshall 4x12
Mics: SM57, Royer ribbon, AKG 414 ("might have been a MD421 there too, or a U87..don´t remember") All blended on to one track.
Bloodbath - Ressurection Through Carnage
Boost: Boss HM-2
Amp: Digitech GNX2 preamp with the "Marshall" amp and speaker sim.
Post Processing: Free Filter plug ripping the EQ curve from Entombeds "Drowned", then applied to the guitar tracks.
Chimaira - Resurrection
Pickup: EMG 81
Boost: Maxon OD820
Amps: Peavey JSX and Krank Krankenstein
Cab: Mesa Oversized 4x12
Mic: Single SM57
Cradle of Filth - Thornography
Pickup: PRS Passive
Boost: Maxon OD820
Amp: Krank Krankenstein
Cab: Mesa Oversized 4x12
Mic: SM57
Despised Icon - Ills of Modern Man
Pickup: EMG 81
Boost: Maxon OD820
Amp: Peavey JSX
Cab: Mesa Oversized 4x12
Mic: SM57
Devildriver - The Last Kind Words
Pickup: EMG 81
Boost: Maxon OD820 on 5150. Dual Rectifier boost unknown.
Amp: Peavey 5150 and Mesa Dual Rectifier
Cab: Dual Recifier into Mesa Oversized with SM57 and MD421 | 5150 into Mesa
Oversized with single SM57
In Flames - A Sense Of Purpose
Pickup: EMG 81
Amps: Orange Tiny Terror, Peavey 5150, Marshall JCM 2203KK
Cabs: Marshall 4x12 (Tiny Terror) Mesa Boogie 4x12 (5150 and JCM)
Mics: "cheap ADK mic" (Marshall cab) SM7 (Mesa cab with 5150) Royer R-122 + SM7 (Mesa cab with JCM)
In Flames - Sountrack To Your Escape
Guitars: Gibson Les Paul and Gibson VooDoo V (Among others)
Pickups: EMG 81
Boost: Electro Harmonix Big Muff
Amp: Peavey 5150
Cab: Marshall 4x12
Job for a Cowboy - Genesis
Pickup: EMG 81
Boost: Maxon OD820
Amp: Peavey 5150
Cab: Mesa Oversized 4x12
Mic: SM57
Kreator - Enemy of God
Pickup: EMG 81
Boost: Maxon OD820
Amp: Peavey 5150
Cab: Mesa Oversized 4x12
Mic: SM57
Masterplan - Aeronautics
Pickup: EMG 81
Boost: TS9
Amp: Mesa Triple Recto 2 ch
Cab: Mesa Oversized 4x12
Mic: SM57
Mastodon - Blood Mountain
Pickup: Seymour Duncan Distortion
Boost: Ibanez Tubescreamer
Amp: Marshall JMP, Marshall JCM800, Laney VH100R, Orange OD100, Mesa Stilleto
Cab: Marshall / Mesa cabs
Mic: SM57, Royer R121
Megadeth - Endgame
Pickup: Mustaine Pickups
Boost: Maxon OD820
Amp: Marshall 410H
Cab: Mustaine Cab
Mic: SM57
Megadeth - United Abominations
Pickup: Mustaine Pickups
Boost: Maxon OD820
Amp: Line 6 Prototype Head. Digital preamp with tube power section.
Cab: Mustaine Cab
Mic: SM57
Nevermore - Dead Heart in a Dead World
Pickup: Emg 707
Boost: TS9
Amp: 4 tracks of Dual Racktifier
Cab: Marshall 1960 with t75
Mic: 2x sm57
Nevermore - This Godless Endeavor
Pickup: EMG 707
Boost: OD820
Amp: Krank Rev 1 and Mesa Boogie Dual Racktifier
Cab: Mesa Oversized 4x12
Mic: SM57
Opeth - Ghost Reveries
Pickup: HFS Treble
Boost: Maxon OD-808
Amp: Mesa Dual Rectifier, POD XT Metal Pack
Cab: Marshall MF400
Mics: SM57, Royer R121
Opeth - Watershed
Pickup: HFS Treble
Boost: Maxon OD-808
Amp: Marshall JVM 410H, Mesa Dual Rectifier
Cab: Mesa Rectifier 4x12, Marshall MF400
Mics: SM57 and Royer R121 on the Mesa cab, 2 SM57 and SM58 on the Marshall cab
Acoustic guitars: U87, 2x 414
Soilwork - Stabbing the Drama
Amp: Mesa Dual Rectifier
Cab: Marshall MF400
Mics: Neumann TLM 127, Royer 121
Testament - The Gathering
Pickup: EMG 81
Boost: None
Amp: Mesa Boogie Triple Rectifier
Cab: Mesa Oversized 4x12
Mic: Beta 57
Testament - Formation of Damnation
Pickup: Dimarzio Super Distortion
Boost: Maxon OD820
Amp: EVH 5150 III
Cab: Matching cab
Mic: SM57
This essentially lists a number of popular records with their reputed rhythm guitar gear lists. Some of them may be incomplete, but this is all of the information we could put together for the time being, as accurately as we could.
You all are welcome to add your own entries to the thread, which may be picked up and tacked on to the OP here. Enjoy.
36 Crazyfists - Rest Inside the Flames
Pickup: Dunacan/Ibanez
Boost: Maxon OD820
Amp: Krank Rev 1
Cab: Mesa Oversized 4x12
Mic: SM57
As I Lay Dying - An Ocean Between Us
Pickup: EMG 85
Boost: Maxon OD820
Amp: Randall Ultra XL Module
As I Lay Dying - Shadows are Security
Pickup: Gibson passives from older Les Paul
Boost: Maxon OD820
Amp: Krank Revolution 1
Mic: Single SM57
Arch Enemy - Anthems of Rebellion
Pickup: Seymour Duncan JB
Boost: Maxon OD820
Amp: Peavey 5150 and XXX
Cab: Marshall 1960AV with V30s
Arch Enemy - Doomsday Machine
Boost: Maxon OD820
Pickup: Seymour Duncan JB
Amp: Krank Revolution 1 and Mesa Dual Racktifier
Cab: Mesa Oversized 4x12
Mic: Single SM57
Between The Buried and Me - The Silent Circus & Self-Titled
Pickups: EMG 85/81
Guitar: Ibanez S520WNF
Amp: Mesa/Boogie dual rectifier rackmount two-channel head
Cab: Mesa Standard Recto 4x12
Between The Buried and Me - Alaska
Pickups - EMG 85/81
Boost - Ibanez TS808
Guitar - Ibanez S1625TKS
Amp - Mesa/Boogie dual rectifier rackmount two-channel head
Cab - Mesa Standard Recto 4x12
Between The Buried and Me - Colors
Pickups - Dimarzio D-Activators
Boost - Ibanez TS808
Effects - Ibanez WD7 Weeping Demon
Guitar - Ibanez S2170FB
Amp - Mesa/Boogie dual rectifier rackmount two-channel head
Cab - Mesa Standard Recto 4x12
Between The Buried and Me - Colors Live
Pickups - Dimarzio D-Activators
Boost - Ibanez TS808
Effects - Ibanez WD7 Weeping Demon
Guitar - PRS Custom 24
Amp - Mesa/Boogie dual rectifier rackmount two-channel head
Cab - Mesa Standard Recto 4x12
Between The Buried and Me - The Great Misdirect
Pickups - Dimarzio D-Activators
Boost - Ibanez TS808
Guitar - PRS Custom 24
Amp - Mesa/Boogie dual rectifier rackmount two-channel head
Cab - Mesa Standard Recto 4x12
Bloodbath - Nightmares Made Flesh
Boost: Boss HM-2
Amp: Marshall DSL50
Cab: Marshall 4x12
Mics: SM57, Royer ribbon, AKG 414 ("might have been a MD421 there too, or a U87..don´t remember") All blended on to one track.
Bloodbath - Ressurection Through Carnage
Boost: Boss HM-2
Amp: Digitech GNX2 preamp with the "Marshall" amp and speaker sim.
Post Processing: Free Filter plug ripping the EQ curve from Entombeds "Drowned", then applied to the guitar tracks.
Chimaira - Resurrection
Pickup: EMG 81
Boost: Maxon OD820
Amps: Peavey JSX and Krank Krankenstein
Cab: Mesa Oversized 4x12
Mic: Single SM57
Cradle of Filth - Thornography
Pickup: PRS Passive
Boost: Maxon OD820
Amp: Krank Krankenstein
Cab: Mesa Oversized 4x12
Mic: SM57
Despised Icon - Ills of Modern Man
Pickup: EMG 81
Boost: Maxon OD820
Amp: Peavey JSX
Cab: Mesa Oversized 4x12
Mic: SM57
Devildriver - The Last Kind Words
Pickup: EMG 81
Boost: Maxon OD820 on 5150. Dual Rectifier boost unknown.
Amp: Peavey 5150 and Mesa Dual Rectifier
Cab: Dual Recifier into Mesa Oversized with SM57 and MD421 | 5150 into Mesa
Oversized with single SM57
In Flames - A Sense Of Purpose
Pickup: EMG 81
Amps: Orange Tiny Terror, Peavey 5150, Marshall JCM 2203KK
Cabs: Marshall 4x12 (Tiny Terror) Mesa Boogie 4x12 (5150 and JCM)
Mics: "cheap ADK mic" (Marshall cab) SM7 (Mesa cab with 5150) Royer R-122 + SM7 (Mesa cab with JCM)
In Flames - Sountrack To Your Escape
Guitars: Gibson Les Paul and Gibson VooDoo V (Among others)
Pickups: EMG 81
Boost: Electro Harmonix Big Muff
Amp: Peavey 5150
Cab: Marshall 4x12
Job for a Cowboy - Genesis
Pickup: EMG 81
Boost: Maxon OD820
Amp: Peavey 5150
Cab: Mesa Oversized 4x12
Mic: SM57
Kreator - Enemy of God
Pickup: EMG 81
Boost: Maxon OD820
Amp: Peavey 5150
Cab: Mesa Oversized 4x12
Mic: SM57
Masterplan - Aeronautics
Pickup: EMG 81
Boost: TS9
Amp: Mesa Triple Recto 2 ch
Cab: Mesa Oversized 4x12
Mic: SM57
Mastodon - Blood Mountain
Pickup: Seymour Duncan Distortion
Boost: Ibanez Tubescreamer
Amp: Marshall JMP, Marshall JCM800, Laney VH100R, Orange OD100, Mesa Stilleto
Cab: Marshall / Mesa cabs
Mic: SM57, Royer R121
Megadeth - Endgame
Pickup: Mustaine Pickups
Boost: Maxon OD820
Amp: Marshall 410H
Cab: Mustaine Cab
Mic: SM57
Megadeth - United Abominations
Pickup: Mustaine Pickups
Boost: Maxon OD820
Amp: Line 6 Prototype Head. Digital preamp with tube power section.
Cab: Mustaine Cab
Mic: SM57
Nevermore - Dead Heart in a Dead World
Pickup: Emg 707
Boost: TS9
Amp: 4 tracks of Dual Racktifier
Cab: Marshall 1960 with t75
Mic: 2x sm57
Nevermore - This Godless Endeavor
Pickup: EMG 707
Boost: OD820
Amp: Krank Rev 1 and Mesa Boogie Dual Racktifier
Cab: Mesa Oversized 4x12
Mic: SM57
Opeth - Ghost Reveries
Pickup: HFS Treble
Boost: Maxon OD-808
Amp: Mesa Dual Rectifier, POD XT Metal Pack
Cab: Marshall MF400
Mics: SM57, Royer R121
Opeth - Watershed
Pickup: HFS Treble
Boost: Maxon OD-808
Amp: Marshall JVM 410H, Mesa Dual Rectifier
Cab: Mesa Rectifier 4x12, Marshall MF400
Mics: SM57 and Royer R121 on the Mesa cab, 2 SM57 and SM58 on the Marshall cab
Acoustic guitars: U87, 2x 414
Soilwork - Stabbing the Drama
Amp: Mesa Dual Rectifier
Cab: Marshall MF400
Mics: Neumann TLM 127, Royer 121
Testament - The Gathering
Pickup: EMG 81
Boost: None
Amp: Mesa Boogie Triple Rectifier
Cab: Mesa Oversized 4x12
Mic: Beta 57
Testament - Formation of Damnation
Pickup: Dimarzio Super Distortion
Boost: Maxon OD820
Amp: EVH 5150 III
Cab: Matching cab
Mic: SM57