Demilich
Remember
so i guess my question is: are all religions that make claims of higher powers equally fallacious?
Well simply saying that the BOM says that Jesus was in America does not disprove it. A better way to disprove the BOM would be to point out the fact that there are over 400 direct qoutations or allusions to NT writings which weren't even written when the BOM books were supposedly written.LORD_RED_DRAGON said:i'm trying to point out the fallacies inherent in each of all the judeo-christianity denominations
I have yet to find one that does not have some serious problem.Demilich said:so i guess my question is: are all religions that make claims of higher powers equally fallacious?
LORD_RED_DRAGON said:so
why is there no text describing where Jesus was between 12 and 30???
Demilich said:there is! do your homework on this one, man. there many texts which discuss contradictory and often controversial descriptions of Jesus' life. they were simply not made part of the canon of Christian literature as were the texts in the Bible. these texts, canonical or otherwise, came from a common pool, and the process of selection undertaken by the church seems to indicate that they were trying to construct an image of jesus that upheld their values and ignored other stories of what he was like.
for example, many stories exist of a young Jesus behaving disrespectfully or even violently to others, including reprimanding a teacher who thought his knowledge exceeded that of Jesus.
religious studies ftw
are you refering to the books that were written in the ethiopian language???Demilich said:there is! do your homework on this one, man. there many texts which discuss contradictory and often controversial descriptions of Jesus' life. they were simply not made part of the canon of Christian literature as were the texts in the Bible. these texts, canonical or otherwise, came from a common pool, and the process of selection undertaken by the church seems to indicate that they were trying to construct an image of jesus that upheld their values and ignored other stories of what he was like.
for example, many stories exist of a young Jesus behaving disrespectfully or even violently to others, including reprimanding a teacher who thought his knowledge exceeded that of Jesus.
religious studies ftw
Thoth-Amon said:The Judeo-Christian deity? Why that one? Why not the Hindu deity or the Deist deity?
Thoth-Amon said:Here we can determine whether or not these Churches are divinely inspired by God using a few simple tests.
1. Have they ever infallibly and officially proclaimed something that is demonstratably false?
2. Have they ever infallibly and officially proclaimed something that contradicts something they have previously infallibly and officially proclaimed?
3. Does their divinely inspried scriptures show evidence of human errors, contradictions, false prophecies, etc.?
4. Have these churches ever officially done or sanctioned something that contradicts their own morality?
Thoth-Amon said:Perhaps what all of you are experiencing is what you PERCEIVE to be your particular deity because you have been conditioned to interpret reality through the matrix of your particular beliefs.
Thoth-Amon said:So is God divinely inspiring the bible's writers to write lies, errors and falsehoods? Wow! What a great and all powerful God! Or isn't it more reasonable to believe that these problems exist in the bible just as they do in other religious texts because they are all the products of human imaginations.
Thoth-Amon said:I was a devout Christian for 13 years.
Thoth-Amon said:Here's the problem. 2 Tim. 3:16 says ALL scripture is inspired by God. Not some, but ALL, every verse even the ones that are clearly erroneous. Now if a scriptural verse has an error or a contradiction then by 2 Tim. 3:16's own description that verse is inspired by God, but how can an error be inspired by God?
Thoth-Amon said:Yes but this brings up several problems. If you admit that there are human errors in the text how do you determine the errors from the divine inspiration?
proglodite said:Through divine inspiration from God Which is how you would also determine whether a minister's sermon rings true - in fact the bible is just one method of God guiding his people, albeit the most studied and accepted one.
Ptah Khnemu said:Umm..... This has been bothering me for a while now, but exactly what causes people to have "Religious experiences"? I've always believed it was people tricking their own minds into these feelings, convincing themselves so strongly that something's happening to them, that th rest of their body responds to it. Care to share your opinions?
exactlyThoth-Amon said:Because no one thought to invent stories about Jesus for those years.
proglodite said:"Religious Experiences" (probably better called 'spiritual guidance') can come from either God, Satan, or - as Ptah suggested - one can be tricked by one's body/mind into believing such an event took place. Differentiating between the three is of utmost importance, and when people fail to do so correctly it can result in christians disagreeing on different aspects of christianity, as Thoth alluded to.