Your Favourite Led Zeppelin album?

Yeah, I've always felt the same myself. I figure you're either a Zep/Stones person or a Beatles/Sabbath person - based entirely off of nothing. :p

Well here it goes for you to think, I´m a Stones/Sabbath person. Don't like Beatles nor Zep.
 
Man, you must really be OLD! I'm getting old and I was just a little kid back in those years. I didn't start getting into music until my early teens, around '78 and '79. But my older brother had all the early 70s classics so I got familiar with those albums by 1980.

I can't say I'm huge into Zep, there's just something about them that's a little "off" to my ears (same as Rolling Stones). But, that said, I do get into Zep moods from time to time and really enjoy any of the first 4 albums immensely. It's a hard decision as to which one's best, but I think I've gotta go with IV. That album featured some of their greatest songs and not a clunker in the bunch.

YEP ! (unfortunantly) soon to be 51. My friends were 2-3 yrs older than me, small town boy, and my cousin who lived in Florida was 3 yrs older too and they were more advanced on the current music scene, word and trends traveled much slower back then, he turned me on to Zep II and I was hooked. Later he also turned me on to Ted Nugent and the Amboy Dukes, Journeys first album, Golden Earings Seven Tears album, Uriah Heep - Look at Yourself, Black Oak Arkansas - Raunch n Roll, Humble Pie - Rockin the Filmore. We already knew about Hendrix of course because he broke thru in the late 60's.

As for the Stones - Beatles - Sabbath thing, I was never much of a fan of any of them, Sabbath the most. Select Beatles and Stones songs we livable on the radio. I was actually the first in my area to discover Sabbath because I listened to this college FM station that had one night a week when some student would come into the studio and play something new they discovered. I had Sabbaths first album recorded from the air waves on one of those old small cassette players, via microphone in front of my AM/FM "transistor" radio.... :lol: "hey guys you have to check this shit out"

So I would disagree some on this scenerio. The Beatles and Stones were old hat and people older than us were more fans than we were. The "new" sound was Zep, Heep, Purple and Sabbath. We were also into more commercial bands like Grand Funk, James Gang, Mountain and the Guess Who. Cream was old by that time too but acceptable for those of us who liked heavy.

Plants vocals - That was part of the catch back then, his amazing wailing on the early albums was what I wanted to hear, it was harsh and powerful. He also sang that high without the falsetto sound, it was just amazing. IV was the last of it, starting with Houses of the Holy we heard a new vocal sound, one which he could do without destroying his voice and most any high stuff was falsetto. I would disagree about him being not a great vocalist too, though I felt he mostly sucked live after I saw the movie. Any singer will tell you that early stuff is hard to pull off and if you listen to songs like Since I've been Lovin You, The Rain Song and Stairway he did have great expression, feel, presentation and dynamics. Granted those that didint like "shrieking" vocals didnt like early Zep or Rush for that matter... lol. But in the days of early hardrock the rest of us loved it. Zep didnt have "hooks" because they were not a commercial band. They became very popular after everyone else caught on but they did not write songs for "hits", but they did write songs that were too good not to get airplay, the rest is history, they changed the music scene, not entirely alone but their impact is undeniable.

IV - I never really liked When the Levee Breaks, Four Sticks, Going to Cali and whatever others, they were not up to par with earlier "lesser" Zep songs and therefore disappointing, it however contained the two gems that did exemplify as well as progress Zep, Stairway and Black Dog. Houses of the Holy carrys many good memories too but had a learning and accepting curve that we would never hear the old band again. My recollection is that the song Dyer Maker is where they gained more attention and acceptance from a broader audience.
 
Well here it goes for you to think, I´m a Stones/Sabbath person. Don't like Beatles nor Zep.

Wyv ! Excluding a few Stones tunes, Hendrix and Cream, Zep is where it all began, all the aggressive heavy pounding... music in yer face... kinda thing.

I could never understand how anyone (into heavy music) could not be impressed by II, man that was released in Oct of '69. Lyrics are mostly silly but that album rocked HARD
 
Wyv ! Excluding a few Stones tunes, Hendrix and Cream, Zep is where it all began, all the aggressive heavy pounding... music in yer face... kinda thing.

I know I'm not your usual type :saint:, it's not rebellion or going against the flow. Actually I was pretty much into the fourth album (my first) because of 'Stairway to Heaven' (never could find the single) when I drifted from pop to rock, but soon the novelty faded.
So now and this is STRICTLY my belief/way of thinking, LZ is not aggressive at all, it's mellow and it bores me.

OK, now you can all come with torches and burn me at the stake :lol:
 
Do you even think II is.... mellow ?

You could easily find youngsters today that would say Maiden is not aggressive because they have spent their time listening to Death and "New" metal.

I think LZ II is more agressive than say DP Machine Head and there is a few years between them, 3-4 I think. Not downing MH either, was in steady rotation at that time.

Im also wondering why you used the word "pop" and that turning to rock was away from Zep ? As far as I know Zep was on the more extreme and progressive side of rock. Im sure today there are also youngsters that would call Maiden or Priest "pop" due to them having a few radio friendly tunes and being softer than _____ current metal band of their choice.
 
Do you even think II is.... mellow ?

That's the other album I have from them (I took it from a cousin who had it but wasn't into rock) and I wanted it because at the time I though LZ had some future with me. But besides the fact that 'Moby Dick' (that I can't even recall how it goes) is on the album nothing have been retained in my memory regarding it.

And I'm not comparing it with "Machine Head" either, as a matter of fact the DP Mk.II albums have good songs, but also a lot of filler, so they're not that astounding either. If I have to compare I have to pick "Black Sabbath" and subsequential albums, not that they were aggressive (aggression for me is thrash) but they have that heavy flavor I never could find in LZ.

Remember, to each its own...madness :loco:
 
Yeah, I dont even listen to them anymore, I got my belly full in the early 70's, but its one kick ass recording and quite important in the history of music, and excluding the song Thank You is far from mellow. I bought Presence on CD because I did want to hear that one again, the rest are pretty much struck to memory. You should give it a bit more play time when in the mood for something different and with the perspective that it was recorded in 69 when no other music sounded like that.
 
when in the mood for something different and with the perspective that it was recorded in 69 when no other music sounded like that.

That's a thought indeed, however on this I'm kind like Hawk these days. I'm not as interested in finding/revisiting really old stuff as looking for new bands with and old school vibe. Besides I'm more an 80's metalhead, I do like a lot of 70's albums (yesterday I was blasting Rainbow first two in my walkman on the gym), but at the end of the day I like more the kick of the 80's traditional metal.
 
Theres an album I'd like to hear again Blackmores Rainbow as well as Black Sabbath, was kinda wishing I had a CD of LZ II once I got talking about it.... lol it would still get my #1 vote as it did "back in the day":cool: have Presence in now "Tea for one" great minor blues, nicely mellow
 
Great discussion. I think a lot of us older guys (razoredge has 9 years on me) who were raised with AM radio and later FM, and were into rock and roll will always have a love for the "classics". I agree with everything razoredge has said. At the time Zep, Purple, Humble Pie, Cream, Sabbath, was the heaviest music you could find. Peroid. It was all blues based too. Blue Cheer did a couple tunes that they called "acid rock", and it was pretty heavy. They all seemed to break ground back then. I remember my Mom didn't want me to listen to Zep cuz I was so young, but when she heard Sabbath, she was like no fucking way! OK, you can listen to Zep but not that devil worship stuff. :lol:

Times were different back then. You got most of your info about the band from the album itself, or the few DJ's that talked about rock. I remember AM radio and they played a lot of soul and Jackson 5 stuff, so when FM came around the big rock acts started sounding awesome. Especially Pink Floyd in my dad's quadraphonic. Funny as hell razor's story of recording an album with the mic from a trasistor radio. :lol:

Again I agree with razor, Zep 2 was the heaviest. Most of the old rockers cite that record as the most infulential to their careers. I can imagine it taking the world by storm in 1969. Back then on the radio you had CCR and the Temptations, Diana Ross, CSN. Then came Zep. Look out! Not even The Who rocked that hard. I guess I just like most all the music from that era.

Something else. Unlike the Who, Zep just burst on the scene and was hugely popular from the first record. And they never had a #1 hit anywhere. A number #1 single back then was really important.

Ok, sorry, I'm rambling again. I just like talking Zeppelin.
 
Great discussion. I think a lot of us older guys (razoredge has 9 years on me) who were raised with AM radio and later FM, and were into rock and roll will always have a love for the "classics".

That's probably the problem with me. I'm 42 and was raised with classical music, opera :puke:, tango :puke: and Argentinian folk music. I then begun with pop as I started highschool, didn´t get into rock until the end of it and that was 82-83, and my exposure through radio of classics was never deep enough, proof of that is that (like I mentioned before) I only liked 'Stairway To Heaven' thus why I bought IV and then get II from my cousin, but didn't gave me as much grip as Def Leppard, Black Sabbath, Iron Maiden, Judas Priest which I get into basically at the same time. I even didn't get into Deep Purple and Rainbow until much, much later, same with Rush not to mention Uriah Heep (which I got into just a couple of years ago).

So the 70's (with a couple of exceptions) is something I didn't get into until way the 80's were gone.

Like I said before, I'm not your usual type :)
 


See I was into that stuff before radio killed it. Some got AM play (around here), Black Dog did I believe, Immigrant song got a few whirls, I cant recall Whole Lotta Love getting play but I think it was a single, I never heard Hey Hey What Can I do untill the mid 70's when FM radio picked it up. We only had that one FM college station (RPI)that rocked sometimes, depended on the student that got the reighns. Seems it was 73 or 74 before we got our first solid FM rock station. Easy Livin got AM play, Hocus Pocus sure did and we thought that was soooo friggin cool... lol. Still love that song.

I was in the opposite position from Wyvern in the early 80's. After a short period of being out of touch with music that wasnt played on the radio. I was exposed to heavier metal, I knew something about it I could relate to, something I undertood, something fimiliar. So I dug back out the few hardrock albums I still had and scavenged through what my friends still had. There I discovered why I found metal fimiliar, old Zep, Uriah Heep, Atomic Rooter, Deep Purple, Black Sabbath, Queens first album, Rushes early stuff (Caress of Steel my fav) "metal" was the latest extension of what these bands started, so its easier for me to make the connection.

Now for me to dig back into the 60's for anything other than the few scarce songs I find little that interests me. Stuff like the Doors, The Beatles, The Who... bla... they couldnt rock hard enough, or draw out that deep mood, all paled by comparision to Zep or Heep or Tull, I wanted to rock or be entertained by some deeper thought, none of that rinky dinky crap
 
See I was into that stuff before radio killed it. Some got AM play (around here), Black Dog did I believe, Immigrant song got a few whirls, I cant recall Whole Lotta Love getting play but I think it was a single,


You got that right. Radio killed rock and roll. Or tryed to. In the 80's when I was in school you didn't get much hard driving rock and roll. By 1985 FM turned to shit in Minn where I was at the time. Hard driving rock and roll was only played when I called and requested it. They thought "metal" was REO Speedwagon and Journy. Both great bands, but not metal.

I felt cheated cuz I didn't know about metal and couldn't find it when I was a kid. So here I am, Wynern's age and only now finding metal. I can bang my head like the kids, but I have to take pain killers afterward. :lol:
 
Easy Livin got AM play, Hocus Pocus sure did and we thought that was soooo friggin cool... lol. Still love that song.


That whole album, Deamons and Wizards is freakin awesome! "The Wizard" is just epic. Hocus Pocus by Focus. Wasn't that the kick ass tune where they yodel? That song rocks!! Got a lot of play way back when, but I haven't heard it in years.
 
That whole album, Deamons and Wizards is freakin awesome! "The Wizard" is just epic. Hocus Pocus by Focus. Wasn't that the kick ass tune where they yodel? That song rocks!! Got a lot of play way back when, but I haven't heard it in years.

Hocus Pocus (yodeling, whistling and some form of grunting... lol) and Frankenstein by Edgar Winter were all the rage for us youngsters around that time. They were both a bit more advanced from the norm and instrumentals to boot. A third instrumental I liked just a much from the same period that got no commercial success for obvious reasons upon hearing it with its long keyboard and drum solo... which kicks some serious ass is Gershatzer by Atomic Rooster. These three songs were mandatory on my weekly listening list. Atomic Roosters second drummer Paul Hammond is worth the price of admission on the lp - Death Walks Behind You, nothing new by todays drummers. He fell somewhere between Bonzo and Mitch Mitchell in style, more jazz flash like Mitchell but equally as talented as either of them

Agree on D&W but Im afraid I killed that without the help of radio, I was so addicted to that album. Then came Rush raising the bar

Helloween did a great cover of Hocus Pocus
 
Helloween did a great cover of Hocus Pocus

Yeah that one came out right by the Pumpkins, can't say the same about 'Locomotive Breath' (Jethro Tull).

Unlike many here, I wasn't into rock radio simply because it didn't exist in my time, and the one it exists was more into 60's rock (and still is, only now they're playing stuff from the 70's and 80's too).

So all the classic stuff you're mentioning came to me way after I was into 80's metal ane even 90's. I came late to Pink Floyd, Focus, Camel, ELP, Yes, King Crimson, Uriah Heep. Some of them I just like, and some I adore.

Yesterday I had a kind of retro hit and played Amboy Dukes, Hendrix and Rolling Stones at night, felt good :headbang:
 
:lol: I used to have Journey to the Center of the Mind and listened to the title track alot, that was epic in its day, weak point is probably the flower childrenish vocals as I recall. Would have maybe sounded better with the more wailing and harsh approach of upcoming hardrock vocalists. It was released in early '68... wow, didnt think it was that old but it did sound old to me in the early 70's compared to what I was listening to. Nugent did well for himself, hard to believe he started in '64/65

I havent heard Helloweens locomotive breath, just Maidens version of Cross Eyed Mary