You guys are way too easy. I mean, whoracle? Purgatory Afterglow? Jeez. listen to "song of sirens" on purgatory afterglow and tell me its perfect, because its not.
In any case, here's what I agree with-
Emperor-Anthems to the welkin at dusk
A truly evil album. From the intro to the end this gives me shivers its so good. Emperor were the band that got me into black metal, and I have yet to hear an album in the genre as flawless as this.
Edge of Sanity-Crimson
The fastest forty minutes ever. The recurring themes make it cohesive, but the variety keeps it interesting. I like moontower better then this, but I can't say it's perfect because some songs don't fit the mood for me. This however has never given me ANYTHING to complain about. Brilliant.
Opeth-MAYH
Still Life is very close to perfect, but little things hold it back. For example, the intro to still life could have been just a little shorter, and it never sounds as convincing the rest of the album as it does on the moor. MAYH however has none of these problems. This album is THE reason I love Opeth as much as I do.