Dunno fellas, but I've really been enjoying this.
A few quick thoughts...
-Like many others, I was surprised by the blast beats and BM sections. Hell, even I was worried that they might take things too far with the post-rock/shoegaze thing, but they have taken it in the opposite direction and I like it. This is further evidenced by the lack of clean vocals. But let's be honest, they didn't fit here much at all. I like that Haughm went with the HEart Of The Ages banshee vocals again (on BLN).
-This may be the only Agalloch album where my brain wanders at any point. It's only about 8 minutes (lasting from the end of TWM through the first 5 mins of BLN). TWM as a whole I find to be the most "traditional Agalloch," and also the most unexciting.
-The drumming does not really bother me (I never really pay attention to it enough to care, unless it REALLY sucks). Since there is a fine line between "simple" and "boring," there will no doubt be many who fall into both camps. I found myself nodding my head a lot more to this album than their others, if that is a good thing.
-Whoever said that BLN resembles Floyd's "Echoes" is right. Not only the structure is similar, but also the melodies. Hell, even the guitar sounds (I'm talking about the part about 3/4 through each song where we get those underwater layered clean "splashing" guitars when the song bursts back into melody from the previous quiet section... EHHH, I'm bad at describing these things...)
-Also, whoever said that the intro to GoMF greatly resembles "She Painted Fire" is also right. I noticed this immediately, and wonder why they didn't catch it or decided to leave it in there. This will probably always annoy me. Also: why did they decide to rip that Requiem For A Dream melody in the final track??? Anyone else notice this? Maybe the boys don't watch TV, but this shit has been in the trailer for every shitty Hollywood action movie since 2003. This will also probably always annoy me.
Anyway, this is hovering at around an 8/10 for me. It makes sense in view of their whole discography, and fits pretty nicely I think.