Well, I've "Rassled" with the new stuff over and over in my head.
I've been a fan since Among the Living, so I have the benefit of prolonged exposure to Anthrax. Wait a minute. That doesn't sound right.
There's no denying the thrash mastery of Among and the following releases. I don't think the albums are quite mixed the way they should have been. Still, they are solid albums, and I can still listen to them to day, which can NOT be said for a LOT of bands.
With Sound of White Noise we got something pretty different. The songs were shorter. The guitar sound was a lot richer. And we got Bush on vocals.
Two things happen here to make me like this less. One, some of the songs have great potential but each one has at least one or two parts where they just don't sound like Anthrax. Kinda like Room For One More at the 35 second mark.
Two, just about every other band I liked changed their sound around this time. Theya ll started lightening up their sound and trying to be more accessible.
Being a young and impressionable young man at that time, it was just another nail in the coffin of thrash.
Along comes Stomp 442. And things start to look really bleak. Now, songs start to have just good parts. Like the first two tracks. Both start ok, then they go downhill around chorus time. One or two don't even sound like they should be on the album at all.
Vol. 8 continues what Stomp 442 started in that the songs are a lot more rock and a lot less heavyiness.
Still, for some reason I feel more encouraged from Vol. 8 than I would think. It certainly has more personality than SOWN or Stomp 442. That's a big plus. Songs like 604, Cupajoe, Toast ot the Extras, Born Again Idiot, are certainly interesting.
In the end, I can certainly understand why the sound continues to evolve. I would rather have THAT than the band be stuck dishing out the same old crap album after album. Sure, songs like Catharisis and King Size make me cringe, but there are a few good flashes here and there.
Final answer, old stuff's awesome, good stuff's not entirely horrible.