'Are you there?' The Gathering's ' you learn about it' ?

[Fragile Dreams]

Well my nice shiny digipak edition of ' A natural disaster' arrived yesterday, and after ripping the cover while getting the inlay out i spun it through a few times! first impressions great! ' Pulled under...' \m/ fuck yes! and then onto my secong fav siong so far on the album, and my point....

Anyone else think ' Are you there?' sounds very, very close to ' You learn about it' from the latest album by The Gathering? everything about that song sounds like ' You learn about it' :Smug:

Im not suggesting there was any copying or anything, and its a great tune, i was just wondering if anyone else noticed that?

 

[sol83]

i disagree. just cos they're both acoustic-based doesn't mean anything.

 

[Achernar]

I can't really hear any resemblances besides both being acoustic-based such as sol said.

 

[Lenore]

me neither

 

[Crack Hitler]

nope. nada. even tho I've only heard said Gathering song a few times.

 

[sol83]

the gathering would deffo fit with anathema tho. imagine a gig like that... and antimatter opening...

*falls of the bed and wakes up*

 

[Mariner]

i even would go to america if they would do that! (i hope not cause i cant spend the money for it) these are me 3 fave bands :hotjump: shouldnt miss em out all together

 

[cedarbreed]

I don't get the connection between the two songs either, except that they both are great tunes

 

[Mariner]

ylai is definately NOT my fave song on 'souvenirs' and 'are you there' neither from 'and'. so yeah they have sth in common. there.

 

[pagan2002]

my favourite tunes by them are travel and sand and mercury. i like them like wouldnt mind a few gigs.

 

[Cerulean]

I wouldn't mind you doing a few gigs with them either!!
It's not impossible is it? I thought they liked Anathema as well.

 

[sol83]

so get in touch with 'em danny! ffs!

 

[sol83]

fuckin' shite. i just went to their website and it says hugo left the band. crap.

but they got a female bass player. nice.

and they're gonna tour next year. (LIKE ANATHEMA WILL *hint*)

 

[Don Corleone]

if there is anything "are you there" resembles, it's sigur ros.

 

[John Carvajal]

me neither

me neither x 100 !!!



Souvenirs kicks *ss!!! :hotjump: oh and song souvenirs is my fav.

does anneke knows anathema?

 

[Usherette]

wow, a TG/Anathema tour will remain in the history of music!

 

[pagan2002]

aye i'll mention it though they are clean non smoking peoples i am not sure how they would take to some hellraising. though i have applied for the open university so i would probably have to do studies in the front of the bus. shame about hugo he was well good on the bass like.

 

[Mariner]

people. behave. he said he wouldnt mind and now you talk like there is already a tour thats been set up... ! cheers john me fave one from the new one is the titletrack as well. and theres no need to get in contact with eachother as both bands know eachother

 

[mehdi.i.e.e.e]

'are you there' reminds me of a french song called 'pas toi' from some local superstar called jean-jacques goldman (arnaud will know). you lads should give that one a go, its very good, nice sad song too.

 

[Mariner]

btw i think hugo left because he has a kid now. or it must be one of the reasons.