- Sep 19, 2018
- 2,540
- 1,277
- 113
- 36
BATTLE OF THE THRASH METAL BANDS (FINAL)
- Thread starter jimmy101
- Start date
Baroque
Active Member
HamburgerBoy
Active Member
- Sep 16, 2007
- 15,042
- 4,850
- 113
Metallica has at least a dozen songs better than the best Slayer song. Not even close.
HamburgerBoy
Active Member
- Sep 16, 2007
- 15,042
- 4,850
- 113
Angel of Death probably isn't even a top 10 Slayer song for me, so limiting it to just songs better than Black Magic, Chemical Warfare, Necrophiliac, and Postmortem (probably my top 4):
Fight Fire With Fire - ridiculously technical and advanced especially for 1984 while also more aggressive than their competition
For Whom the Bell Tolls - total anthem and classic of epic metal
Fade to Black - peak metal ballad
The Call of Ktulu - ambition and atmosphere still unapproached by most of their progeny today with no gimmicks attached
Master of Puppets - self-evident
The Thing That Should Not Be - this was several years ahead of both death metal in terms of drop-tuned heavy churning and tech-metal like Confessor/Meshuggah in terms of unwieldy rhythms and arrangement
Disposable Heroes - main riff reduced to a single heavily-syncopated open-string note yet they successfully get 8 minutes of intense and thematic thrash out of it
Orion - Ktulu pt 2 except exploring a totally different theme in a rather different way
I guess I'll retract the 'dozen' qualification though I'd say Motorbreath, Jump in the Fire, Escape, Creeping Death, Sanitarium, Damage Inc, Blackened, and One are at least competitive with Slayer's best.
Slayer is obviously great and if being purely numerical about direct copycats of their sound, they still win. But they never had the full package of those eight Metallica songs. You'd have to cherry-pick the greatest individual moments of the Slayer discography, maybe somehow meld the bridge of Necrophiliac, the hardcore break of Kill Again, and the melodic tension of Hallowed Point to make a single song to beat any of those eight.
Fight Fire With Fire - ridiculously technical and advanced especially for 1984 while also more aggressive than their competition
For Whom the Bell Tolls - total anthem and classic of epic metal
Fade to Black - peak metal ballad
The Call of Ktulu - ambition and atmosphere still unapproached by most of their progeny today with no gimmicks attached
Master of Puppets - self-evident
The Thing That Should Not Be - this was several years ahead of both death metal in terms of drop-tuned heavy churning and tech-metal like Confessor/Meshuggah in terms of unwieldy rhythms and arrangement
Disposable Heroes - main riff reduced to a single heavily-syncopated open-string note yet they successfully get 8 minutes of intense and thematic thrash out of it
Orion - Ktulu pt 2 except exploring a totally different theme in a rather different way
I guess I'll retract the 'dozen' qualification though I'd say Motorbreath, Jump in the Fire, Escape, Creeping Death, Sanitarium, Damage Inc, Blackened, and One are at least competitive with Slayer's best.
Slayer is obviously great and if being purely numerical about direct copycats of their sound, they still win. But they never had the full package of those eight Metallica songs. You'd have to cherry-pick the greatest individual moments of the Slayer discography, maybe somehow meld the bridge of Necrophiliac, the hardcore break of Kill Again, and the melodic tension of Hallowed Point to make a single song to beat any of those eight.
CiG
Approximately Infinite Universe
I like Slayer and Metallica's early stuff about equally, but Metallica's overall career is worse than Slayer's imo.
- Sep 19, 2018
- 2,540
- 1,277
- 113
- 36
Yeah AoD isn't my favourite Slayer song either. But 1000% agree that Metallica's instrumental songs are better than anything Slayer has ever done.
- Sep 19, 2018
- 2,540
- 1,277
- 113
- 36
Are they? The only Metallica material that could be considered better than Slayer's best work is their classic stuff from the 80's (which is easy to get nostalgic about).
You'd have to rid yourself of nostalgia to do with both bands if you are to look at it objectively.
CiG
Approximately Infinite Universe
I like how Slammed had to say something crazy just to really drive it home that he was trolling Jimbo.
- Sep 19, 2018
- 2,540
- 1,277
- 113
- 36
He spreads his wings especially on St Anger. Nothing quite like substituting a snare for a jerry can imo.
Slammed
Active Member
- Jun 15, 2017
- 31,453
- 45,124
- 113
My first sound engineering job I made the drummer from Taipan's drum kit sound like he was using ice cream buckets, so maybe it's not all Lars' fault....then again maybe it is
CiG
Approximately Infinite Universe
- Sep 19, 2018
- 2,540
- 1,277
- 113
- 36
It definitely is Lars' doing. Lars is super well-known for being controlling/pedantic about the way his drums are mixed. IIRC in an interview with the guy who produced AJFA & he said that Lars would bring in photos of a mixing board with each of the levels exactly where he wanted them to be. Wouldn't listen to anything the producer said about changing it for the better. Apparently he was on the verge of quitting his producer job all throughout the recording of that album.
Lars also told him face to face to omit any bass guitar on the record. Years later, Lars would approach him at some function being all like "You didn't really scoop the bass out of the mix did you?"
The guy was pretty annoyed by that.
Lars also told him face to face to omit any bass guitar on the record. Years later, Lars would approach him at some function being all like "You didn't really scoop the bass out of the mix did you?"
The guy was pretty annoyed by that.
Similar threads
