post yours!
people that don't like grindcore/goregrind are just narrowminded
That is one of the stupidest comments I have ever seen. I hate grind, I can't stand it, but I can tell you right now that I am not narrowminded whatsoever, I just don't enjoy it.
Now to get back to the topic, here's mine (not necessarily controversial, more just my thoughts that usually get argued with):
Load IS a decent album, so is St Anger, but Metallica are nothing overly special in the first place anyway. Ride the Lightning and Kill 'em All are boring albums.
Like somebody above said, I hate black metal bands that purposely have shit production on their albums.
Dream Theater are boring as bat shit. I can't stand bands that spend all their time trying to be technical and their music ends up having nothing enjoyable about it.
Iced Earth with Ripper on vocals is awesome. It's doesn't match up to Barlow's material of course, but they are fucking MASSIVE shoes to fill and I think Ripper is doing a mighty fine job.
Drone is shit. I fail to see anything even slightly enjoyable about that genre in general, in fact I fail to see how most drone "songs" are actually classed as proper songs.
There's nothing at all wrong with cheesy power metal (such as Manowar), it's all in good fun.
Similar to the previous point, there's nothing wrong with fake-satanism in music (Slayer for example), it's all in good fun, it's entertainment remember.
There's nothing wrong with bands becoming commercially succeful.
There's nothing wrong with a band re-recording old songs for a compilation or anything similar, especially when the bands sound has changed a lot.
Not every band has to be "original". Why does it matter if a band sounds like another band? Or they have similar riffs? If you enjoy it, then it just means you have twice as much good music to listen to.