People claiming Priest are overrated are just as silly as that opinion. You can't have both words "Priest" and "overrated" in one sentence.
I disagree with that. There's definitely differences between everything, the instruments, the vocals, even production. Possessed was heavier than any thrash band, in every regard.
How are they not over rated? They have 16 (17,18?) albums, 3 or 4 of which are excellent, a small handful good, and the rest varying between decent and shit, mostly being shit. Irrespective of this fact they're worshiped as heavy metal gods. It's obviously due to their legacy as pioneers, which is rightly deserved, but based purely on musical output? Yea, undeniably over rated.
I disagree with that. There's definitely differences between everything, the instruments, the vocals, even production. Possessed was heavier than any thrash band, in every regard.
The guitar riffs remind me a lot of 90's metalcore, but more technical.
GMD: Where we disagree with death metal pioneers
If I am defining death metal to someone, the first thing I focus on is the vocals. Sure, they exist in other genres spattered about (Sadus and such), but the main distinguishing factor of death metal against all other genres is vocal style. Same goes for black metal, but you could also argue production style there.
The only albums that you could consider 'bad' from Judas Priest are Jugulator (although Cathedral Spires is nuts) and maybe Painkiller. The reason I say Painkiller is because it's trendhopping and there are only a few tracks on that record that aren't boring in my opinion. and maybe half of Point of Entry, but that has some killer tunes on it.
The use of growling vocals by bands like Between the Buried and Me, Agalloch, and Thou are inconsistent with the music; I suspect they only do it because they couldn't find a proper singer.
I disagree with that. There's definitely differences between everything, the instruments, the vocals, even production. Possessed was heavier than any thrash band, in every regard.
I do agree that the growls make little sense to Agalloch's music…..and they make less sense in modern Enslaved. (Gods I wish Grutle would just stop it already!) But I tend to think these bands *want* this vocal style and aren't just settling on it because they can't find a true singer. for good or bad, it's part of the aesthetic.