Controversial opinions on metal

[The Ozzman]

sure, i get why someone who worships incantation wouldn't like the chasm. i'm in the opposite camp really, i like a little melody in my DM. oppressive murk has its place but it works more as background music for me, it doesn't keep my attention.



i have the opposite opinion. they've been getting more and more streamlined, predictable and bloated over the years. still one of the best bands around though.

have you really heard their first two BTW? i wouldn't expect you to like them more than DEATHCULT but maybe i'm wrong.

I listened to the following albums. I've only listened to Procession, Deathcult and Farseeing more than once:

Procreation of the Inner Temple
From The Lost Years...
Deathcult
Procession
Conjuration of the Spectral Temple
The Spell of Retribution
Farseeing
Reaching the Veil of Death

 

[Dak]

i still sorta like DISCOURAGED ONES and TONIGHT'S DECISION despite the awkward songwriting and moping about, but they got really shitty later on. i can imagine them being dreadful live.

I know their later material isn't popular with the trve crowd, and bands are usually in the habit of playing mostly newer stuff, so that would make them terrible by default.

More specifically and generally what I meant was that music of a melancholy nature isn't something I want to "share", and that would include having the band physically present. Plus, I can see how that type of music doesn't translate into a live venue presentation. The melancholy thing also goes for most of the BM that I listen to - absolutely no reason to see it live.

 

[The Ozzman]

I like everything after Brave Murder Day.

 

[The Butt]

I never got into Katatonia. They never connected with me.

 

[no country for old wainds]

I listened to the following albums. I've only listened to Procession, Deathcult and Farseeing more than once:

Procreation of the Inner Temple
From The Lost Years...
Deathcult
Procession
Conjuration of the Spectral Temple
The Spell of Retribution
Farseeing
Reaching the Veil of Death

based on your love of FARSEEING you should probs give SPELL more listens, it's the most similar

 

[The Ozzman]

I plan on giving everything more listens. I've procured so much stuff recently I'm drowning haha

 

[KafkaX]

Katatonia is fucking incredible. There isnt one thing in their discography I do not like, except for that acoustic album...

I will say the first time I saw them live I was really disappointed...Disappointed in how fucking gay their fans are. No movement. No energy. No nothing.

 

[The Ozzman]

Katatonia is fucking incredible. There isnt one thing in their discography I do not like, except for that acoustic album...

I will say the first time I saw them live I was really disappointed...Disappointed in how fucking gay their fans are. No movement. No energy. No nothing.

What did you think of Dead End Kings?

 

[EternalMetal]

I like everything after Brave Murder Day.

Im the opposite. I like Dance of December Souls and BMD, and thats it. Their sound changed and they got much more melancholy, and it reminds me of the type of stuff that emo teenagers who suck at life choose to off themselves to. Whereas with the older stuff I get the feeling of catharsis through isolation. To me BMD was their peak, and simultaneously their turning point into constant paced and depressive boring crap.

 

[Dak]

I will say the first time I saw them live I was really disappointed...Disappointed in how fucking gay their fans are. No movement. No energy. No nothing.

That's the thing with melancholy music though. What are you supposed to "do" to it? You're not going to be moshing to Idle Blood.

 

[J.]

The Chasm is great. Procession, Conjuration, and Farseeing are my favorites. Like Ozz, Deathcult doesnt really grab me.

I like some Incantation, but it doesnt hold my attention throughout. And yes, they're samey throughout their discography

Post BMD emo rock sucks.

 

[Pitiless Wanderer]

Luckily you don't have to imagine anything about Katatonia live. Just go watch them on Youtube. Some, not all, of the performances are stellar, but that's like any band. I think they have tons of energy live and most of the crowds seem to be into them.

 

[KafkaX]

What did you think of Dead End Kings?

I thought it was good, but not their best.

I liked Night Is The New Day better.

That's the thing with melancholy music though. What are you supposed to "do" to it? You're not going to be moshing to Idle Blood.

I totally hear you, but fuck man, no one even sang along or head banged. Even on more aggressive songs like My Twin, Leaders, Forsaker etc.

I get it, but still like wtf...

 

[Pitiless Wanderer]

That's the thing with melancholy music though. What are you supposed to "do" to it? You're not going to be moshing to Idle Blood.

A lot of their music is very groovy and headbangable, no?

 

[CiG]

I actually don't mind their depressive Rock stuff.

 

[The Ozzman]

Shit, my voice would be hoarse at the end of My Twin if I ever saw that band live.

 

[KafkaX]

Yeah that whole album is pretty delicious. The first 3 (post BMD) are the ones I listen to the most.

Was going to try and put a controversial opinion about their best album in this post, but that shit is just too hard to pick.

 

[CiG]

Of the post Brave Murder Day records I definitely have to go with Tonight's Decision myself.

 

[The Ozzman]

Was going to try and put a controversial opinion about their best album in this post, but that shit is just too hard to pick.

Viva Emptiness

 

[KafkaX]

I was gonna go with TD, but LFDGD is fucking top notch as well...So many good songs on both...And the fucking feels on DO???? Jesus christ...Cant pick. Wont pick.

Viva Emptiness was actually the first album I listened to from them. Back when I actually bought CD's...While it is a good album I personally cant say its their best.