Controversial opinions on metal

Controversial opinion: Lamb of God made a pretty good song once, or more specifically, half of a pretty good song. The first 2 minutes or so of "Walk With Me In Hell" (up to "now witness the end of an age") are badass.

I am by no means a LoG or metalcore fan but the new songs from Wrath on their myspace sounds pretty badass... especially Set to Fail.
 
How about:

Everything Killswitch Engage has done has been the epitome of excellence
yes, they are all good.

...

i like industrial, symphonic, melodic, and progressive black metal (Samael, Dimmu, Naglfar, Enslaved, etc.) quite a bit, but hate most if not all pure black metal, including Emperor, Immortal, Gorgoroth, Darkthrone, etc. no matter how much i try to be trve and like it, and oh i have tried
 
i like industrial, symphonic, melodic, and progressive black metal (Samael, Dimmu, Naglfar, Enslaved, etc.) quite a bit, but hate most if not all pure black metal, including Emperor, Immortal, Gorgoroth, Darkthrone, etc. no matter how much i try to be trve and like it, and oh i have tried

I've never thought of Emperor as "pure" black metal, which is why I believe I love them.
 
Man I seriously cannot understand how people prefer Brave Murder Day to Dance of December Souls, dance is godly and BMD is not.
 
A. Chevelle is not metal.
B. You couldn't find a more embarrassing band that I like, seriously? I feed you guys this shit, and you can't even deliver when you have the chance.
C. Killswitch might be tolerable from time to time, but "the epitome of excellence" is taking that a bit far.

They are more than tolerable, especially the first two albums
 
I've never liked a single thing Katatonia ever did, I prefer Paradise Lost. The only good thing about Katatonia is that the singer has a nice name.
 
Controversial opinion: Lamb of God made a pretty good song once, or more specifically, half of a pretty good song. The first 2 minutes or so of "Walk With Me In Hell" (up to "now witness the end of an age") are badass.

Controversial opinion: I like everything LoG has done.
 
Controversial opinion: I like everything LoG has done.

I wouldn't say I like everything (since Burn the Priest is pretty aweful) but they have definitely been getting better and better. I don't see why they are so disliked unless it is the lack of kvltness.

Been listening to Wrath today, pretty solid album, it lacks a killer track like Walk with Me in Hell and Redneck, but over all it is better than Sacrament.
 
I wouldn't say I like everything (since Burn the Priest is pretty aweful) but they have definitely been getting better and better. I don't see why they are so disliked unless it is the lack of kvltness.

Been listening to Wrath today, pretty solid album, it lacks a killer track like Walk with Me in Hell, but over all it is better than Sacrament.

Well, I haven't heard Burn The Priest, but I've heard everything they've put out under the name of Lamb of God.

And IMO, Reclamation is the "killer track" on Wrath. Fuck, that shit was just amazing.

All in all, Wrath's a solid album though... they're trying something different here; and while not as good as Sacrament, it's a great album regardless.
 
How eloquently rebutted.
Well, tbh, it was an idiotic point. It's like saying you can't like Iron Maiden if you don't like Genesis. And also, I question that Bathory were heavily influenced by Zeppelin. Tbh usually people accuse Hammerheart of ripping off Manowar.
Ditto. This says nothing about the music.
The music wasn't relevant to that point so...
Also, I mentioned the music was crap. Happy?

Drumming is not part of the music? Bonham was one of the first outside of jazz to play drums not just as a metronome but like a lead instrument.
Music: what you get when you put all the instruments together. You can have tedious music with great drumming.

I can understand people not having a taste for Plant but on that basis you'd have a hard time enjoying Priest, Maiden and most power metal.
My problem isn't that he sings high, my problem is his colossally annoying voice. So, no, actually, I have no problem enjoying Priest, Maiden, and most power metal.

You obviously haven't listened much then because 'Dazed and Confused' is only one of the most famous basslines ever.
Is that the one where Plant moans until I hit the skip button? I think I might have let that play out once because I wasn't paying attention, but I honestly can't recall the bassline.

Congratulations on citing an internet source which you don't understand. Those allegations can basically be dismissed by one of the following:
1. 'plagiarism' was commonplace in blues and not considered objectionable.
2.Choose any of the heavier rock albums of the period and look at the number of covers (Jeff Beck, Yardbirds etc)
3. the majority of those songs were radically altered
4. those songs were basically Zep's formative period as they carved out a new style and really were not those that made them famous.
Okay, that's great. Of course, considering Zep's reputation as being innovative, I consider this significant. However, if you'd read the whole post you would have noticed the part where I took back "hacks."

vihris-gari said:
I like how you mention turning Zeppelin off after 3 minutes. As in, you've already made up your mind about the band before actually making any attempt at appreciating their music.
Actually, I meant I can't really listen to his voice for more than three minutes. I've made multiple attempts to get into them, and have about 8 hours of their stuff on my comp my friend lent me, maybe half of which I've listened to.

Really, there's just no defense for such an epic fail at hard rock opinions as those quoted above. If you can't get over the attitude of bands like Zeppelin and AC/DC enough to actually give them an open-minded listen, then don't make ignorant-ass posts about them.
The attitude doesn't bother me; songs about rocking and sex and drinking and leaving women are fine. What bothers me is that neither band writes music that I find remotely interesting. I passed through the brief phase almost every guy goes through in seventh grade where AC/DC are the epitome of all that is awesome and then one day I realized that Angus Young's guitar-playing was actually really boring and their music was childish. I don't have a problem with people who like them, although there are a lot of people who wear AC/DC shirts who don't like their music.