Controversial opinions on metal

[meaperson333]

James Murphy is a fantastic guitarist who should be more well known.

How is this controversial? I don't think I know anyone who dislikes him.

 

[gundamterran]

Some people seem to think he's too robotic, I just wonder what drugs they're taking, and where can I get them.

 

[VelociBrad]

His work on Dreams of the Carrion Kind is top notch.

 

[meaperson333]

I always thought he had tons of emotion in his playing, especially on Spiritual Healing.

 

[gundamterran]

haha. His work is the only thing that keeps me listening to Cause of Death.

 

[meaperson333]

yeah, he's just awesome in general.
also for a controversial opinion
Effigy of the Forgotten > Pierced From Within

 

[Satanstoenail]

Some people seem to think he's too robotic, I just wonder what drugs they're taking, and where can I get them.

Why would you want drugs that make one of your favorite guitarists sound shit?

 

[The Ozzman]

Effigy of the Forgotten > Pierced From Within

That statement is true and, therefore, not controversial

 

[Mayhem_MetalHead]

Altars of Madness has one of the greatest death metal guitar tones ever....

I agree, but im talking about Covenant. Great album but i wish it had a sharper tone like Altars of Madness


And no, Pierced From Within > Effigy of the Forgotten. But thats just me

 

[WCannibal]

Con't: Human Waste > Effigy and Pierced

 

[V.V.V.V.V.]

False overall, but there is some material on HW that is better than similar (and even dissimilar) material on the quoted albums.

 

[wandering_taco]

Can't we just say that Suffocation is better than most things?

 

[HamburgerBoy]

And even if it was exactly the same riff and it was known that Sodom deliberately lifted the riff for use in their own song, that would still be irrelevant when the riff is placed in an entirely different context.

I'm talking about the verse riff, which is used in identical context.

http://www.divshare.com/download/6497754-0d1

(the Megadeth riff is included too; skip to 0:28 for the Sacred Reich riff)

You know how many thrash riffs sound similiar, every Kreator riff for example is almost indentical to Slayer's, but no one points that out.

Probably because Slayer riffs are indeed largely samey. It's easier to notice when Kreator rips off Exodus instead.

 

[Mayhem_MetalHead]

I'm talking about the verse riff, which is used in identical context.

http://www.divshare.com/download/6497754-0d1

(the Megadeth riff is included too; skip to 0:28 for the Sacred Reich riff)



Probably because Slayer riffs are indeed largely samey. It's easier to notice when Kreator rips off Exodus instead.

Like how Cold Demons by Vader sounds almost exactly like a Slayer riff, i just can't remember which one.

People "take" riffs all the time, but they usually aren't identical, and if the band is respectable then they always make it sound their own and it usually isn't on purpose. It's hard to not sound atleast a little like the great bands that came before you and influenced you...

 

[HamburgerBoy]

To be fair I could name many favorite songs of mine guilty of a riff filching or something equivalent, but if the band can do it in a way different than the original ("context") I don't really care. I know that Metallica admits to outright taking one of Sanitarium's riffs from Rush's Tom Sawyer, but when they are open about it and do it in a way almost unrecognizable I have absolutely no problem with it. Sodom's Agent Orange is an already uncreative band trying to squeeze an album out of their filthy asshole after ingesting as many other band's works as possible. The late 80's were terrible for the lower-first/upper-second tier bands, all of them hearing nothing but Big 4 this and MTV that and saying "Hai, we can do that too!" See Overkill's Elimination for a similarly uninspired song.

 

[Caligulan Blood]

I like hollywood undead and brokencyde :/

 

[gundamterran]

Your worse then that NokturnalNemifag. :| lol.

 

[-CC-]

I like hollywood undead and brokencyde :/

 

[sevag00]

You know how many thrash riffs sound similiar, every Kreator riff for example is almost indentical to Slayer's, but no one points that out.

r u srs?

 

[ArneZ]

Slayer is for most part a boring recycle riff machine, Kreator`s not. Both bands blew in the 90s though, with exception of Coma of Souls which is one of the greatest thrash metal albums of all time.