We had a blast playing Heathen Crusade that one year, and we haven't been asked back again.
That was a phenomenal performance, and quite frankly, the enthusiastic reception probably had much to do with the fact that the other bands on the roster followed a similar theme. All things considered, Novembers Doom being enveloped in a roster by the likes of Moonsorrow and Thyrfing playing their first ever US shows is extraordinary event planning.
I don't think any small concert (as opposed to a Wacken-like event) should encourage
rotational fan attendance. Meaning, one set of fans wait at the bar and then rotate over with another set of fans leaving the hall. If all bands follow a similar enough theme, I'd assume you'd want to strive toward having ALL the fans wanting to see ALL the bands, no?
we can either look at this with a positive spin, as we've been doing, and try to make something good out of it. Or we can just cancel and not play. Which would be pretty lame, in my opinion.
Absolutely.
There is no doubt you should play this event. Again, hats off to Rob & co for putting the show on in the first place, I'm sure there is an entire story of how this show came together.
The one thing I just disagree with some people about is that they think there's no chance for diehard, cool new young fans to be won or found in a Devildriver or Soil crowd.
Perhaps, and of course that would be great but I fear you might have those fans not even turning up until their bands are ready to take the stage. Or they'll wait at the bar as I mentioned earlier. Of course, I hope this is not the case.
Furthermore, even at a show like that, for as many people as might be turned onto us, how many people would just turn their noses up at us because they're "Opeth snobs" and think every band like us is just some wannabe?
Sure, it's possible but less likely. History would suggest that some of the greatest metal concerts of all time comprised rosters with bands all complimenting each other.
And the people who support us but can't justify coming out to see us at this particular fest, we still appreciate your support and hope to see you at the next show
Of course.
Hey, I drove from New York to Cambridge one night (with wife and kids in tow after hearing that L'Amours shut down and you had to skip the NYC show) to see you guys play with Agalloch and The Gathering in the basement of the Middle East bar. But honestly? Speaking as a long time fan, had you been playing that night with DevilDriver and Soil, I would have stayed at home.