karma and reincarnation also imply moral standards to live up to in order to advance towards Nirvana over the course of multiple lives - it's not just a consolation for life's crappy moments, since it depends on your own behavior whether the starting circumstances in the next life will be more or less pleasant than the current onemy dying groom said:I'd like to believe in the immortality of our so-called souls. But what kind of solace would I gain from that? None.
I mean, most spiritually related ideas aim at installing a positive bigger picture to ease life's crappy moments. Let's say our souls are immortal... so what? "Ah death's not that bad, it's not like we're losing everything." Well then, our spiritual essence shall remain, but what for? This is the interesting part. To be immortal for immortality's sake? To indulge in our own greatness? To commune with other souls (something that could already be done in physical form)? With God? It leads to nothing. The only thing it would do is exalt us beyond other life forms on earth - if flora and fauna is as inferior as mankind assumes.
Probably I'm just too young and too cynical to grasp the fascination of it
What is the difference between living up to certain moral standards to enter nirvana and living up to rules presented by some kind of god to enter heaven (or similar places for good guys)? It's a pity we need rewards to do so anyway.Alwin said:karma and reincarnation also imply moral standards to live up to in order to advance towards Nirvana over the course of multiple lives - it's not just a consolation for life's crappy moments, since it depends on your own behavior whether the starting circumstances in the next life will be more or less pleasant than the current one
exactly this is considered morally wrong in buddism and hinduism - good work should be done, but not for the fruits of it - this attitude is to be strifed formy dying groom said:What is the difference between living up to certain moral standards to enter nirvana and living up to rules presented by some kind of god to enter heaven (or similar places for good guys)? It's a pity we need rewards to do so anyway.
Yes, a very desirable attitude.Alwin said:exactly this is considered morally wrong in buddism and hinduism - good work should be done, but not for the fruits of it - this attitude is to be strifed for