I was bored so I thought I would take up playing GTA 4 again. The last time I played it a year or so ago I hated it, and guess what, nothing's changed.
The problem is the controls and the camera. I'm not only talking about the driving here, simply moving around on foot is awkward as hell. First of all, for some reason I can't fathom, you can't jog simply by pushing the left stick forward. Instead you have to push the stick forward while holding the X button. This makes it impossible to aim your gun with the right stick while jogging or sprinting, because your thumb is occupied with the X button. It also makes it impossible to even see where you're going or what's nearby while jogging (especially in stairs).
Second, the camera itself is sluggish, when you change direction the camera is always slightly delayed. Also, if you want to look to the sides while running the character himself will change direction. This, coupled with the character himself responding stiffly to your commands, takes away any of the joy you could have felt while interacting with the world.
Gunfights are also crap. When you're in cover, the character takes a year to respond when you press the shoot button, and if you don't hold the button in he will get back into cover immediately. The aiming also sucks ass. Since your enemies can take like five gunshots to the body you don't want to use auto aim, but if you remove it in order to be able to aim at people's heads, it becomes too hard to hit them.
This game is so overrated. The intricacy of the world is impressive and all, but it isn't fun to play at all.