Yeah man, did the maths again, definitely counted.
TechnicalBarbarity
-TheNightsBane-
In four cases, the math doesn't look right for me, at least not, if I count the votes mentioned below the albums in concern.
"Beneath the Remains" got (3x10+2x9+8+3x7+6+4+3+4x2=) 98 points, whereas "Nothingface" only got (4x10+9+3x8+6+4x3+2+1=) 94 points, thus they both switch places. "Consuming Impulse" only got (3x9+2x8+6x7+5+2x4+4x3+2=) 112 points and thus drops one place. And "Altars of Madness" - though this won't affect its ranking - only got (5x10+6x9+8+3x7+6+2x5+2x4+1=) 158 points.
"Beneath the Remains" got (3x10+2x9+8+3x7+6+4+3+4x2=) 98 points, whereas "Nothingface" only got (4x10+9+3x8+6+4x3+2+1=) 94 points, thus they both switch places. "Consuming Impulse" only got (3x9+2x8+6x7+5+2x4+4x3+2=) 112 points and thus drops one place. And "Altars of Madness" - though this won't affect its ranking - only got (5x10+6x9+8+3x7+6+2x5+2x4+1=) 158 points.
Somethingface
Member
It's because CiG types my name (and some others) in invisible font on most of those you listed. Assuming they have been counted but just not listed, like the other one that got fixed. 
TechnicalBarbarity
-TheNightsBane-
well i was the one who started the last few polls and yea none of your votes were counted in those. I'm pretty sure they were here though.
Just looked over it again and i think i've spotted a mistake. It looks like Beneath the Remains and Nothingface both have 98 points and should be tied.
Morbid Angel
4+9+5+6+6+7+5+10+7+9+9+9+10+9+4+1+8+10+10+7+10+7+9 = 171
Pestilence
9+8+2+7+9+3+4+3+4+3+7+7+5+7+7+8+7+3+9+7 = 119
Sepultura
10+7+8+2+10+7+9+3+2+2+2+4+6+9+10+7=98
Voivod
3+8+9+8+2+8+1+10+10+3+10+10+6+4+3+3+= 98
Just looked over it again and i think i've spotted a mistake. It looks like Beneath the Remains and Nothingface both have 98 points and should be tied.
Morbid Angel
4+9+5+6+6+7+5+10+7+9+9+9+10+9+4+1+8+10+10+7+10+7+9 = 171
Pestilence
9+8+2+7+9+3+4+3+4+3+7+7+5+7+7+8+7+3+9+7 = 119
Sepultura
10+7+8+2+10+7+9+3+2+2+2+4+6+9+10+7=98
Voivod
3+8+9+8+2+8+1+10+10+3+10+10+6+4+3+3+= 98
@Somethingface's votes counted this time.
Just double-checking all my maths now, I immediately see I fucked up Sepultura. I'll have all this fixed asap lmao.
@Burkhard your Voivod re-calculation is based on the 'voted for by' list I assume, which means you missed Somethingface's ranking of the album at 7th. My bad I forgot to add his name in that section, Voivod at 98 is correct.
Pestilence is also correct at 119, I forgot to put @Allfader's name in the 'voted for by' section so you missed his 7 points.
Same shit with Morbid Angel, sorry I just missed a bunch of names in the 'voted for by' section herp derp.
Just double-checking all my maths now, I immediately see I fucked up Sepultura. I'll have all this fixed asap lmao.
@Burkhard your Voivod re-calculation is based on the 'voted for by' list I assume, which means you missed Somethingface's ranking of the album at 7th. My bad I forgot to add his name in that section, Voivod at 98 is correct.
Pestilence is also correct at 119, I forgot to put @Allfader's name in the 'voted for by' section so you missed his 7 points.
Same shit with Morbid Angel, sorry I just missed a bunch of names in the 'voted for by' section herp derp.
Last edited:
Allfader
Kvelding
Consvming Impvlse is highly regarded. I'm not totally surprised that it made it to the top 10, but I'm surprised it bested Beneath the Remains, provided Sepultura was considered a top tier band with far more exposure and commercial acclaim, whereas Pestilence has been seen as second tier for most of its lifetime.
TechnicalBarbarity
-TheNightsBane-
no country for old wainds
Active Member
- Nov 23, 2002
- 26,570
- 9,583
- 113
regardless of the order, it's a top ten that cannot be fucked with.
no country for old wainds
Active Member
- Nov 23, 2002
- 26,570
- 9,583
- 113
one of the most straight up vivid metal albums in my book. every song paints a distinct picture.
HamburgerBoy
Active Member
- Sep 16, 2007
- 15,042
- 4,848
- 113
Allfader
Kvelding
crimsonfloyd
Active Member
Allfader
Kvelding
I'm still kinda surprised you had Carcass at #2 dude, for some reason I never had you for a fan of goregrind, even if it is top tier that transcends the subgenre.
crimsonfloyd
Active Member
It’s a fucking great album. Interesting compositions, great riffs. My tastes are pretty dynamic, so it shouldn’t be too surprising.
Similar threads
