HamburgerBoy
Active Member
- Sep 16, 2007
- 15,042
- 4,723
- 113
The first suspicion I would have is that he treats the last couple decades as an unusual trend towards polarization, rather than admitting that the New Deal period (going up to the 1970s) was a time of unusual non-polarization. Our democratic system is polarized virtually by design, <Vox>and that's a good thing</Vox>.
EDIT: To be fair, I checked his Twitter...
tbf, first tweet I agree with and goes against my concern, second tweet is garbage if "majoritarian political identities getting stronger" is a dogwhistle for "white males getting stronger" but might make sense in some other context, third paragraph is kind of obvious but vague. I think Vox is basically total garbage, but I think I've seen individual Klein pieces that were reasonably cogent by the standards of American leftism. Like, most of the stuff The Intercept publishes lately is probably even worse than Vox, but the top guys like Greenwald are still reasonable.
EDIT: To be fair, I checked his Twitter...
It feels impossible to describe in a few tweets a project I've been working on for years, but here goes: American politics isn't broken. It's working as structured. We need to understand that structure, and the incentives of the players in it.
At the core of this story is "identity politics," but not the narrow, weaponized version we tend to hear about. We need to understand identity much more broadly, and see the way majoritarian political identities work, and why they're getting so much stronger.
~A lot~ of the way political institutions work now is by activating and reinforcing certain political identities. And that sets of feedback loops where the institutions polarize, an that further polarizes the public, which forces institutions to polarize more, which further...
tbf, first tweet I agree with and goes against my concern, second tweet is garbage if "majoritarian political identities getting stronger" is a dogwhistle for "white males getting stronger" but might make sense in some other context, third paragraph is kind of obvious but vague. I think Vox is basically total garbage, but I think I've seen individual Klein pieces that were reasonably cogent by the standards of American leftism. Like, most of the stuff The Intercept publishes lately is probably even worse than Vox, but the top guys like Greenwald are still reasonable.
Last edited: