Ok so after quite a lot of listenings (and I mean a LOT!! lol) I can finally give my opinion about this new album Immortal.
I think you guys achieved quite a memorable disc with this new one.
I can honestly say that I have never been a huge fan of Lance King's voice (no doubt he's a good singer but just not my taste) which kinda held me back a little bit on the first two records.
With Matt (who is one my all time favorite singer) into the picture, things are obviously very different. He brought what I think lacked the most on MB and LOTBC: ballsy and raging vocals yet very melodic and full of emotion. His delivery on the album is out of this world, I mean I could go into an hour long discussion about how awesome his voice sounds. Just pure gold and most probably his best performance up until now (which says a lot).
Obviously the singing is not the only important thing in an album like this, but I think it's the key element that make the real difference.
Musically, I would say that the album is a typical Pyramaze record, meaning that the sound is very close to what you can hear on LOTBC, maybe a tad heavier and darker, but not that much actually. The playing is absolutely top notch, every member bring exactly what the songs require, and don't go into an overplaying mode which is good. (and yes I am a Dream theater fan too lol!)
The songs are all powerful and emotionally intense, and the chemistry between the style of the songs and Matt's voice is surprisingly magic! All songs are very solid and no fillers can be found. My personal favorite is The Highland, although A beautiful death (300 yea!!) and Shadow of the beast are very close.
My only concern would be the mix, who sometimes bring the keyboards a little bit too much into the picture, drowning the voice and the guitars. But hey Jonah nothing against your performance which I think is stellar! (especially on Legacy in a rhyme)
Overall I think the album came out great, and it's just too bad that this collaboration will be the only one. There is a real strong chemistry going on here, and I hope that you guys will find the perfect vocalist to "replace" Matt.
Urban Breed would be great, I love his voice, and he would fit well indeed!