Oh, I remember this place.
Last time I posted here was in the lead-up to SOAPF's release, I think. In retrospect, that album was pretty great, though I don't listen to it all that much these days. That's mostly because Siren Charms wound up, somehow, being tied with TJR as my favorite IF album. I don't even know what it is. I just fucking enjoy it from start to finish. Those two records - TJR and SC - are easily my most-played from IF these days.
But Battles is giving me conniptions because I don't know what to make of THIS BAND ANYMORE.
Here are my 100% illegal and wrong opinions of these two new songs.
"The End" is a fun, solid track. I'd say it's their strongest lead single since "Take This Life," and holy shit it's nice to have an IF song with good production. Anders's vocals are the highlight here. Barring ASOP and parts of SOAPF, I've always been cool with Anders's cleans, and I'd say this is him at his best. The verses have a nice R2R-style groove, and that pre-chorus ("I can't tell you what to do / this crossroad is your own...") is probably my favorite section. Love the bridge, too - Anders's cleans and Bjorn's lead make a neat combination and create a ton of cool atmosphere. Bjorn's solo has grown on me, too. Lately I've been thinking he's been growing a bit stale, but like, if the 14-year-old me had heard this solo, I would've gone nuts.
But just, holy shit, get that choir of kids out of there. Guys. What were you thinking. And that chorus is way too Bring Me The Horizon for my tastes. But yeah, this is a good one, albeit flawed.
"The Truth" seems to be roundly hated. Which of course means this one's more my speed. I like Experimental In Flames, although you can call it Sellout In Flames if that suits you. This'll come across as shitposting but I was actually surprised to hear the allegations of "pop song!" toward this. On first listen, this reminded me of DT's "Misery's Crown." I wish I was joking. And I actually like this song more than "Misery's Crown." Semi-upbeat metal track with clean verses, clean vocals with great melodic hooks, a (relatively) positive vibe, and great harmonized leads. The point being that it's not like this kind of song hasn't been done in the Gothenburg scene before, let alone metal, so seeing all these "WHOOOAAAARGH" reactions was kind of strange.
The main things I like here are the verses, especially the "I hear the sound of a plane/car" sections. Love that clean lead layered over Anders's vocals. That's some 80's shit right there, so naturally I'm a fan. The chorus has some cool guitar work, too. Listen to when Anders sings "We are the truth that hurts the most" - there's a great guitar lick there that almost makes the whole song for me. Yeah, the song is pretty poppy. But In Flames has always been poppy as far as metal goes. I can't be mad about it.
If they feature Adam Levine on this album, though, I will flip shit. Some lines you just do not cross.
My big problem with "The Truth" is that, yeah, I like it a lot, but there's an even better, 200% more hype version of this song called "Filtered Truth" that I could listen to just as easily. And, again, get those kids and that clapping out of there. You're 40-year-old dudes, In Flames. You're not fooling anyone.
Anyway, I'm keeping my hype for Battles in check. I've never really agreed that IF was actively chasing a "made-for-radio" sound, but it's so overt with these two songs that even I can't deny it now. We'll see.
EDIT: I am really curious to see if the new drummer can play even half of their back catalog. I'd have to see it to believe it. Or hear it, etc. You know what I mean.