The saddest thing in this board is the underappreciation of ASOP. Everyone just follows the herd of blahblah with better production it eould've been okay blahblah, which is true, but the truth is, it's an outstanding record to follow up CC with.
The power, sound, intensity of CC was unmatchable, and as great as it was, it strayed very far from traditional IF? even farther than STYE in many aspects. ASOP was of the humblest return to their older style, and I rarely see people appreciate that.
The fact is, on an individual basis, every song beats out SOAPF songs. SOAPF is a good record to listen from start to finish, it has everything a record needs to have, unlike ASOP which is "just" a bunch of great songs thrown together without much connection between them. Would it be weird if March to the Shore opened the record, and TMT closed it? Not at all. Try the same with Liberation and SOAPF and it doesn't work at all.
But I myself am not big on listening to albums from start to finish. It's very rare that I feel an urge to pop in a record to listen to it start to finish. I jump around a lot, and there is barely any reason to listen to many songs from SOAPF. But ASOP just works perfectly. ASOP is the modern day TJR/Whoracle.
The only bad thing for me is Anders, as he is just weak there, and I don't know why. Like, how the fuck can this quality go through post-production? "From into neeeeeeeeeeeew groooouuuuuunddddsssssssssssssssss" no, just no.
And honestly, it says a lot about how fuckin great of a record ASOP is, when basically everything great on that record is pure guitar work. I'm really not the type of guy, who gets an erection some very technical, cool metal track, like yeah, cool, nice, how about some not shitty vocals so I could enjoy this trash, eh? But ASOP is great, probably the best guitar work since Clayman, and I highly doubt there will ever be a record where they can über it.
And it honestly saddens me how many people fail to see this. Clayman was the last record you can hear remnants of old IF, but even that record took it in a weird direction. ASOP is like in TJR/Whoracle where it did not want to be anything special. It's so pure.