illbeleavinnow
Member
The Moor may be l33t, but When is the guy that beats up the geek who says l33t, thus making When far superior to The Moor.
Opeth Song Survivor - Tournament Final - 4 Remaining (Vote for least favourite)
- Thread starter no country for old wainds
- Start date
Smitty
Prick
The Moor? Better than When and TBYF? You've gotta be kidding me...I'm voting against Bleak, it's the weakest out of the list (and shouldn't of made it to this round) but The Moor is the most overrated out of the bunch.
illbeleavinnow
Member
April Ethereal is fucking amazing. Best song off MAYH. And The Leper Affinity is the best song off BWP. Those two songs are so amazing if I heard both of them in a row I'd explode (sexually-wise).
- Nov 23, 2002
- 26,855
- 9,722
- 113
- Nov 23, 2002
- 26,855
- 9,722
- 113
- Nov 23, 2002
- 26,855
- 9,722
- 113
illbeleavinnow said:@ Azogue, for a while I loved The Moor much more than When. I think why everyone at one point or another falls in love with When (and all of MAYH) is because the song never gets old. Whereas Bleak, The Moor, The Drapery Falls, etc lose some of thehir charm after a while and they become fabricated. When and the rest of MAYH will always be enjoyable at its fullest.
I just wish more people would cross over to this stage.
Precisely. When is a far better song, The Moor is just catchier and has that great riff. I adored it, but I got quite bored of it. There isn't enough in the song for me. Granted, it's the best song on Still Life, but MAYH is in a different class to that album. Still Life has those bits where you think 'that's just brilliant' or 'mm, beautiful'. My Arms Your Hearse never stops being brilliant or beautiful at any point. Still Life's song structure is too polished for me as well. I've had When for longer. I've listened to When more. I still love When far more.
- Nov 23, 2002
- 26,855
- 9,722
- 113
illbeleavinnow said:
1. The Leper Affinity
-----------------------
2. The Funeral Portrait
3. Blackwater Park
-------------------------
4. Bleak
----------------------------
5. The Drapery Falls
6. Dirge for November
7. Harvest
The Leper Affinity is better than Bleak
And, less Demon of the Fall, I'd put When behind April Ethereal and The Amen Corner.
And, less Demon of the Fall, I'd put When behind April Ethereal and The Amen Corner.
illbeleavinnow
Member
WyldeBill speaks the truth. It seems our constant bitching has worked GoD.
ANd I agree totally with what you said about Still Life and MAYH. I love every Opeth album, but the first three, especially MAYH and Morningrise, are absolutely brilliant. I never get tired of them. Every moment spent listening to any song off those albums is a great moment.
Oh, and since I think this is really fun:
ORCHID
1 - Forest of October
2 - In Mist She Was Standing
3 - Under the Weeping Moon
4/5 - The Apostle in Triumph, The Twilight is My Robe (these two just haven't sunk in yet, unfortunately)
MORNINGRISE
1 - Black Rose Immortal
notworthy)
2 - The Night and the Silent Water (almost as good as BRI)
3 - To Bid You Farewell
4 - Advent
5 - Nectar (sadly, not a very good song)
MAYH
1 - April Ethereal
2 - When (although When is slowly becoming better than April)
3 - Demon of the Fall
4 - The Amen Corner
5 - Karma
6 - Credence (just because I like Karma more)
STILL LIFE (this is gonna be wild, I still have to give it a few more good listens)
1 - The Moor
2 - Serenity Painted Death
3/4 - Godhead's Lament, White Cluster
5 - Moonlapse Vertigo
6 - Face of Melinda
7 - Benighted
BWP
1 - The Leper Affinity (GODLY)
2 - Funeral Portrait
3 - Bleak
4/5 - The Drapery Falls, Blackwater Park
6 - Dirge For November (if it wasn't so repetative, it'd be great)
7 - Harvest
DELIVERANCE (what is about to follow is completely coincidental)
1 - Wreath (you never know how good a song is until you stop listening to it)
2 - Deliverance
3 - A Fair Judgment
4/5 - Master's Apprentices, By the Pain I See In Other
DAMNATION
1 - Windowpane
2/3 - Rid the Disease, In My Time of Need
4 - Hope Leaves
5 - Closure
6 - Ending Credits
7 - Death Whispered a Lullaby
8 - Weakness
There's my list.
ANd I agree totally with what you said about Still Life and MAYH. I love every Opeth album, but the first three, especially MAYH and Morningrise, are absolutely brilliant. I never get tired of them. Every moment spent listening to any song off those albums is a great moment.
Oh, and since I think this is really fun:
ORCHID
1 - Forest of October
2 - In Mist She Was Standing
3 - Under the Weeping Moon
4/5 - The Apostle in Triumph, The Twilight is My Robe (these two just haven't sunk in yet, unfortunately)
MORNINGRISE
1 - Black Rose Immortal
notworthy)2 - The Night and the Silent Water (almost as good as BRI)
3 - To Bid You Farewell
4 - Advent
5 - Nectar (sadly, not a very good song)
MAYH
1 - April Ethereal
2 - When (although When is slowly becoming better than April)
3 - Demon of the Fall
4 - The Amen Corner
5 - Karma
6 - Credence (just because I like Karma more)
STILL LIFE (this is gonna be wild, I still have to give it a few more good listens)
1 - The Moor
2 - Serenity Painted Death
3/4 - Godhead's Lament, White Cluster
5 - Moonlapse Vertigo
6 - Face of Melinda
7 - Benighted
BWP
1 - The Leper Affinity (GODLY)
2 - Funeral Portrait
3 - Bleak
4/5 - The Drapery Falls, Blackwater Park
6 - Dirge For November (if it wasn't so repetative, it'd be great)
7 - Harvest
DELIVERANCE (what is about to follow is completely coincidental)
1 - Wreath (you never know how good a song is until you stop listening to it)
2 - Deliverance
3 - A Fair Judgment
4/5 - Master's Apprentices, By the Pain I See In Other
DAMNATION
1 - Windowpane
2/3 - Rid the Disease, In My Time of Need
4 - Hope Leaves
5 - Closure
6 - Ending Credits
7 - Death Whispered a Lullaby
8 - Weakness
There's my list.
I had to vote off bleak.... I don't really know what it's doing here. I mean, I love the song, but I really prefer Deliverance, To rid the disease and for that matter The Drapery Falls.... Anyway I think my favourite is winning
- Nov 23, 2002
- 26,855
- 9,722
- 113
illbeleavinnow said:Oh, and since I think this is really fun:
ORCHID
1 - Forest of October
2 - In Mist She Was Standing
3 - Under the Weeping Moon
4/5 - The Apostle in Triumph, The Twilight is My Robe (these two just haven't sunk in yet, unfortunately)
MORNINGRISE
1 - Black Rose Immortal (!)
2 - The Night and the Silent Water (almost as good as BRI)
3 - To Bid You Farewell
4 - Advent
5 - Nectar (sadly, not a very good song)
MAYH
1 - April Ethereal
2 - When (although When is slowly becoming better than April)
3 - Demon of the Fall
4 - The Amen Corner
5 - Karma
6 - Credence (just because I like Karma more)
STILL LIFE (this is gonna be wild, I still have to give it a few more good listens)
1 - The Moor
2 - Serenity Painted Death
3/4 - Godhead's Lament, White Cluster
5 - Moonlapse Vertigo
6 - Face of Melinda
7 - Benighted
BWP
1 - The Leper Affinity (GODLY)
2 - Funeral Portrait
3 - Bleak
4/5 - The Drapery Falls, Blackwater Park
6 - Dirge For November (if it wasn't so repetative, it'd be great)
7 - Harvest
DELIVERANCE (what is about to follow is completely coincidental)
1 - Wreath (you never know how good a song is until you stop listening to it)
2 - Deliverance
3 - A Fair Judgment
4/5 - Master's Apprentices, By the Pain I See In Other
DAMNATION
1 - Windowpane
2/3 - Rid the Disease, In My Time of Need
4 - Hope Leaves
5 - Closure
6 - Ending Credits
7 - Death Whispered a Lullaby
8 - Weakness
There's my list.
Hehe.
ORCHID (I like these two instrumentals
)1. Silhouette
2. Requiem
3. In Mist She Was Standing
4. The Twilight is my Robe
5. The Apostle in Triumph
6. Forest of October (I NEED THIS TO SINK IN PROPERLY)
7. Under the Weeping Moon
MORNINGRISE
1. Black Rose Immortal
2. The Night and the Silent Water
3. To Bid You Farewell
4. Advent
5. Nectar
MAYH
1. April Ethereal
2. When
3. Demon of the Fall
4. The Amen Corner
5. Karma
6. Credence
7. Epilogue
STILL LIFE
1. The Moor
2. Serenity Painted Death
=3. Benighted
=3. Face of Melinda
=3. Godhead's Lament
=3. White Cluster
7. Moonlapse Vertigo
BLACKWATER PARK
1. The Leper Affinity
2. The Funeral Portrait
3. Blackwater Park
4. Bleak
5. The Drapery Falls
6. Dirge for November
7. Harvest
DELIVERANCE
1. A Fair Judgement
2. Deliverance
3. Wreath
4. Master's Apprentices
5. BTPISIO
DAMNATION
1. Closure
2. To Rid the Disease
3. In My Time Of Need
4. Hope Leaves
5. Death Whispered A Lullaby
6. Ending Credits
7. Windowpane (never clicked)
8. Weakness
illbeleavinnow
Member
You guys are lame...Epilgoue #7 on MAYH?
Anyway while we're all at it here's my list:
Orchid:
1. Twilight is my Robe
2. Apostle In Triumph
3. Forest of October
--------------------
4. In the Mist She Was Standing
--------------------
5. Under the Weeping Moon
6. Requiem
7. Sillhouette
Morningrise
1. Black Rose Immortal
----------------------
----------------------
----------------------
2. Advent
3. To Bid You Farewell
4. The Night and Silent Water
5. Nectar
MAYH
1. April Ethereal
2. Demon of the Fall
3. When
-------------
4. Epilogue
5. The Amen Corner
-------------
6. Karma
7. Credence
-----------
8. Madrigal
9. Prologue
Still Life
1. Moonlapse Vertigo
2. Serenity Painted Death
----------------
3. The Moor
4. Face of Melinda
5. White Cluster
----------------
6. Godhead's Lament
7. Benighted
BWP
1. Leper Affinity
2. Blackwater Park
---------------
3. Bleak
4. The Funeral Portrait
5. Dirge for November
---------------
6. Drapery Falls
7. Harvest
8. Patterns in the Ivy
Deliverance
1. Master's Apprentices
2. Wreath
-----------
3. By the Pain I see in Others
4. Deliverance
----------
5. A Fair Judgement
Damnation
1. In my Time of Need
2. Windowpane
--------------
3. Closure
4. Ending Credits
5. To Rid the Disease
--------------
6. Death Whispered A Lullaby
7. Hope Leaves
8. Weakness
Anyway while we're all at it here's my list:
Orchid:
1. Twilight is my Robe
2. Apostle In Triumph
3. Forest of October
--------------------
4. In the Mist She Was Standing
--------------------
5. Under the Weeping Moon
6. Requiem
7. Sillhouette
Morningrise
1. Black Rose Immortal
----------------------
----------------------
----------------------
2. Advent
3. To Bid You Farewell
4. The Night and Silent Water
5. Nectar
MAYH
1. April Ethereal
2. Demon of the Fall
3. When
-------------
4. Epilogue
5. The Amen Corner
-------------
6. Karma
7. Credence
-----------
8. Madrigal
9. Prologue
Still Life
1. Moonlapse Vertigo
2. Serenity Painted Death
----------------
3. The Moor
4. Face of Melinda
5. White Cluster
----------------
6. Godhead's Lament
7. Benighted
BWP
1. Leper Affinity
2. Blackwater Park
---------------
3. Bleak
4. The Funeral Portrait
5. Dirge for November
---------------
6. Drapery Falls
7. Harvest
8. Patterns in the Ivy
Deliverance
1. Master's Apprentices
2. Wreath
-----------
3. By the Pain I see in Others
4. Deliverance
----------
5. A Fair Judgement
Damnation
1. In my Time of Need
2. Windowpane
--------------
3. Closure
4. Ending Credits
5. To Rid the Disease
--------------
6. Death Whispered A Lullaby
7. Hope Leaves
8. Weakness
illbeleavinnow
Member
Karma and Credence are amazing songs. Credence isn't the best or even top three of Opeth's best mellow songs but Karma is so much better than:
Wreath
Master's Apprentices
By the Pain I See in Others
Nectar
The Apostle in Triumph
The Twilight is My Robe
Godhead's Lament
White Cluster
The Drapery Falls
and many more (I'm counting heavy songs only). Karma = teh win. I'm sorry if it hasn't sunk into you yet, it's a beautiful song.
Wreath
Master's Apprentices
By the Pain I See in Others
Nectar
The Apostle in Triumph
The Twilight is My Robe
Godhead's Lament
White Cluster
The Drapery Falls
and many more (I'm counting heavy songs only). Karma = teh win. I'm sorry if it hasn't sunk into you yet, it's a beautiful song.
![[0hr]Sunlapse](https://ultimatemetal-data.community.forum/avatars/l/12/12972.jpg?1086073981){kind=avatar}
[0hr]Sunlapse
Wraith
Fuck you all Bleak is the best on this list you guys and your damn song lists and shit and bleak is losing and you hate nectar for some reason and bleak isn't gonna win, shit wtf the fuckin' moor gimme a break bleak'll fucking blow it away
diso
waiting anxiety
Hmm...
Orchid -
The Twilight Is My Robe
Forest Of October
Requiem (including the half on The Apostle In Triumph)
Under The Weeping Moon
The Apostle In Triumph
Silhouette
In Mist She Was Standing
Morningrise -
To Bid You Farewell
Advent
Nectar
The Night And The Silent Water
Black Rose Immortal (ack)
MAYH -
Demon Of The Fall
Epilogue
When
Karma
Credence
April Ethereal
The Amen Corner (I just don't like it that much.)
Prologue (doesn't really count =P)
Still Life (this is where the goods are at
-
White Cluster (hail my favorite song)
Face Of Melinda
The Moor / Moonlapse Vertigo
Benighted
Serenity Painted Death
Godhead's Lament (used to be my favorite, now I hate it
)
BWP (including the bonuses) -
The Leper Affinity
Harvest
Blackwater Park
The Funeral Portrait / The Drapery Falls
Still Day Beneath The Sun
Patterns In The Ivy II
Dirge For November
Patterns In The Ivy
Deliverance (took me forever to decide) -
Wreath / Masters Apprentices / Deliverance
A Fair Judgement
For Absent Friends
By The Pain I See In Others
Damnation (ugh...) -
Windowpane
Ending Credits
Weakness
Hope Leaves
In My Time Of Need
Death Whispered A Lullaby
Closure
To Rid The Disease
That was fun. Now for my top ten overall...
1. White Cluster
2. To Bid You Farewell
3. Face Of Melinda
4. The Leper Affinity
5. Harvest
6. Demon Of The Fall
7. Epilogue
8. The Twilight Is My Robe (I want to say I like it more than DOTF, but...) / Forest Of October
9. Blackwater Park (this should probably be farther up there...
10. Windowpane
So it's really 11... oh well.
Orchid -
The Twilight Is My Robe
Forest Of October
Requiem (including the half on The Apostle In Triumph)
Under The Weeping Moon
The Apostle In Triumph
Silhouette
In Mist She Was Standing
Morningrise -
To Bid You Farewell
Advent
Nectar
The Night And The Silent Water
Black Rose Immortal (ack)
MAYH -
Demon Of The Fall
Epilogue
When
Karma
Credence
April Ethereal
The Amen Corner (I just don't like it that much.)
Prologue (doesn't really count =P)
Still Life (this is where the goods are at
-White Cluster (hail my favorite song)
Face Of Melinda
The Moor / Moonlapse Vertigo
Benighted
Serenity Painted Death
Godhead's Lament (used to be my favorite, now I hate it
)BWP (including the bonuses) -
The Leper Affinity
Harvest
Blackwater Park
The Funeral Portrait / The Drapery Falls
Still Day Beneath The Sun
Patterns In The Ivy II
Dirge For November
Patterns In The Ivy
Deliverance (took me forever to decide) -
Wreath / Masters Apprentices / Deliverance
A Fair Judgement
For Absent Friends
By The Pain I See In Others
Damnation (ugh...) -
Windowpane
Ending Credits
Weakness
Hope Leaves
In My Time Of Need
Death Whispered A Lullaby
Closure
To Rid The Disease
That was fun. Now for my top ten overall...
1. White Cluster
2. To Bid You Farewell
3. Face Of Melinda
4. The Leper Affinity
5. Harvest
6. Demon Of The Fall
7. Epilogue
8. The Twilight Is My Robe (I want to say I like it more than DOTF, but...) / Forest Of October
9. Blackwater Park (this should probably be farther up there...
10. Windowpane
So it's really 11... oh well.
MasterOLightning
Optimator
Karma is the forgotten Opeth song in my mind. I think it's very underrated. It's just so overshadowed by AE, When, and DotF. Karma beats The Amen Corner though.
The Night and the Silent Water. This is my favorite song off of MR. I never get tired of this song. Too bad Mike and Peter hate this song and will never play it live.
I can make a list too.
Orchid
1. In Mist
2. The Apostle in Triumph
3. Forest of October
4. Twilight is my Robe/Under the Weeping Moon
6. Requiem
7. Silhouette
Morningrise
1. The Night and the Silent Water
2. Advent
3. BRI
4. TBYF
5. Nectar. I think Nectar is good, but blown away by the other four tracks.
MAYH
1. When
2. AE
3. Demon
4. Karma
5. Epilogue
6. The Amen Corner
7. Credence
8. Madrigal
9. Prologue
Still Life
1. Moonlapse Vertigo
2. SPD/ White Cluster
4. Godhead's Lament
5. Face of Melinda
6. The Moor
7. Benighted
BWP
1. The Leper Affinity
2. BWP
3. Bleak
4. Funeral Portrait
5. Drapery
6. Dirge
7. Harvest
8. Patterns
Deliverance
1. Deliverance
2. MA
3. Wreath
4. BTPISIO
4. A Fair Judgement
5. For Absent Friends
Damnation
1. Closure
2. Windowpane
3. In My Time of Need
4. To Rid the Disease
5. Death Whispered a Lullaby
6. Ending Credits
7. Hope Leaves
8. Weakness
The Night and the Silent Water. This is my favorite song off of MR. I never get tired of this song. Too bad Mike and Peter hate this song and will never play it live.
I can make a list too.
Orchid
1. In Mist
2. The Apostle in Triumph
3. Forest of October
4. Twilight is my Robe/Under the Weeping Moon
6. Requiem
7. Silhouette
Morningrise
1. The Night and the Silent Water
2. Advent
3. BRI
4. TBYF
5. Nectar. I think Nectar is good, but blown away by the other four tracks.
MAYH
1. When
2. AE
3. Demon
4. Karma
5. Epilogue
6. The Amen Corner
7. Credence
8. Madrigal
9. Prologue
Still Life
1. Moonlapse Vertigo
2. SPD/ White Cluster
4. Godhead's Lament
5. Face of Melinda
6. The Moor
7. Benighted
BWP
1. The Leper Affinity
2. BWP
3. Bleak
4. Funeral Portrait
5. Drapery
6. Dirge
7. Harvest
8. Patterns
Deliverance
1. Deliverance
2. MA
3. Wreath
4. BTPISIO
4. A Fair Judgement
5. For Absent Friends
Damnation
1. Closure
2. Windowpane
3. In My Time of Need
4. To Rid the Disease
5. Death Whispered a Lullaby
6. Ending Credits
7. Hope Leaves
8. Weakness
segaszivos
Member
I think that TO BId You Farewell might be my least favorite song on MAYH... so, I am happy with this outcome. ^_^
Similar threads
- Poll
- Poll
- Poll
- Poll