Rate all Opeth albums 1-10

[Slynt]

1-10, compared to all my other metal albums.

'Orchid' - 9.5
'Morningrise' - 9.5
'My Arms, Your Hearse' - 9.5
'Still Life' - 9.8
'Blackwater Park' - 8.3
'Deliverance' - 8.5
'Damnation' - 7.0
'Ghost Reveries' - 9.0
'The Roundhouse Tapes' - 9.5
'Watershed' - 8.5

 

[Under the weeping spoon]

Orchid - 9
Morningrise - 9.5
My arms your hearse - 10
Still life - 8.5
Blackwater Park - 9
Deliverance - 8
Damnation - 8
Ghost reveries - 8.5
Roundhouse tapes - 9
Watershed - 8

 

[αlphaWhore]

Orchid - 6.5
Morningrise - 8
My Arms, Your Hearse -9
Still Life - 9
Blackwater Park - 10
Damnation - 8
Deliverance - 7
Ghost Reveries - 10
Watershed - 10

 

[Glühwürmchen]

Orchid - 6,5
Morningrise - 7,5
My Arms, Your Hearse - 8,5
Still Life - 10
Blackwater Park - 9,5
Deliverance - 8
Damnation - 9
Ghost Reveries - 9,5
Watershed - 9,25

Couldn't get into Orchid yet, it's a bit too raw for my taste, but maybe after a few additional spins,
I will appreciate it as much as the other albums.

 

[Cognitive Intercourse]

For whatever it's worth:

'Orchid' - 7
'Morningrise' - 9
'My Arms, Your Hearse' - 8
'Still Life' - 9
'Blackwater Park' - 9
'Deliverance' - 9
'Damnation' - 10
'Ghost Reveries' - 9
'The Roundhouse Tapes' - 9
'Watershed' - 8

 

[Autumn eye]

Orchid - 10
Morningrise - 8
My Arms Your Hearse - 9
Still life - 8
Blackwater Park - 9
Deliverance - 9
Damnation - 9
Ghost Reveries - 8
Watershed - 6

 

[Karppaky]

Orchid - 9
Morningrise - 10
My Arms, Your Hearse - 10
Still life - 9
Blackwater Park - 10
Deliverance - 7
Damnation - 10
Ghost Reveries - 8
Watershed - 8

 

[Slaydon]

I'm amazed that so many of you give 10 and 9 to Orchid. You must be in your early teens obviously!

 

[Hedon-]

^i dont like orchid very much myself but the post above me lacks logic

 

[Vega Skater]

I'm amazed that so many of you give 10 and 9 to Orchid. You must be in your early teens obviously!

I wish my opinion was superior like Slaydon's.

Orchid isn't my favourite, but it gets the most play in my world.

 

[anus slayer ov the dogs]

^i dont like orchid very much myself but the post above me lacks logic

I agree...

 

[Uthark]

I'm amazed that so many of you give 10 and 9 to Orchid. You must be in your early teens obviously!

You're the moron who wanted Mikael to stop using harsh vocals, right?

Orchid is a very good album.

 

[Lenni]

I'm amazed that so many of you give 10 and 9 to Orchid. You must be in your early teens obviously!

I don't know any 13 year olds who listen to orchid but those who do are ahead of the usual limp bizkshit stuff imo.
Hell it's harder to get into this album than other Opeth albums with all the growling and confuse song structure.

 

[anus slayer ov the dogs]

I don't know any 13 year olds who listen to orchid but those who do are ahead of the usual limp bizkshit stuff imo.
Hell it's harder to get into this album than other Opeth albums with all the growling and confuse song structure.

I know a 12 year old who listens to Opeth for over a year and knows a lot about them...

 

[anus slayer ov the dogs]

But true he isn't really into Orchid specifically

 

[Eternalnow]

Orchid is the hardest Opeth album to get into, imho, but once you do its fucking amazing!

 

[Slaydon]

Orchid is the hardest Opeth album to get into, imho, but once you do its fucking amazing!

Amazing?? How can you call those boring repetitions of the same goddamn notes amazing? And if those notes were good, like on Morningrise. I could stand all the repetitions and monotony as long as the basic melody was good.

 

[Eternalnow]

Amazing?? How can you call those boring repetitions of the same goddamn notes amazing? And if those notes were good, like on Morningrise. I could stand all the repetitions and monotony as long as the basic melody was good.

Different strokes?

Granted it is nowhere near the quality of later recordings, but it certainly holds its place...

 

[uber-engl]

Orchid - 1
Morningrise - 1
My Arms, Your Hearse - 1
Still Life - 5
Blackwater Park - 9
Deliverance - 6
Damnation - 7
Ghost Reveries - 10
Watershed - 8

only opeth 1-10

 

[Slaydon]

Orchid - 1
Morningrise - 1
My Arms, Your Hearse - 1
Still Life - 5
Blackwater Park - 9
Deliverance - 6
Damnation - 7
Ghost Reveries - 10
Watershed - 8

only opeth 1-10

Ouch. This is gonna be ugly.:Smug: