My two favourite albums are Follow the Reaper and Are You Dead Yet? - so you can sort of see that I have sort of an almost "centered" taste in their sound, not really siding with old or new.
I have to agree that their new stuff is easier to take, like most songs on Are You Dead Yet?, except for some of the tracks on Blooddrunk. Songs like "Done With Everything", "Roadkill Morning", and "LoBodomy" (though one of my absolute favourites) would be easier to pull a melody out of, than, say, "Towards Dead End" or "Downfall", for example - though I guess it's all in one's own ears.
Anyways, I can say that I actually love all of COB's albums to an extent, so for me it doesn't really matter what they play live, or what they prefer. I think what's important, and what makes COB's music so personal to me is that I can feel the heart and emotion that is put into it - even the songs that aren't my particular favourites.
From an artist's perspective, music or painting or any kind of art has to be something you want to put your heart into. Art should come naturally and an artist should love what they are doing, not trying to be something they're not - otherwise they lose themselves. It's the same as if you are trying really hard to dress or act a way which you think you should or everyone will like - it doesn't feel right, and you begin to question yourself or hate what you are doing.
If a band is content and enjoying the music that they are playing, and continually inspired, then that to me is a good thing and they should keep doing what they are doing - even if their music begins going in a different direction, or gets more popular or whatever else of these "bad" things.
A good example that I know of is AFI. I was really into their early stuff - which was raw, hard-core punk. When they released Decemberunderground, I was kind of like, "Well, this is okay, but not really my thing." Then they released Crash Love this year, and it really showed me that, well, they've grown into a different band than I grew up with. But that's okay - it's nothing to be pretentious about, they're just different now.
Any good artist will grow, and will change - and Alexi, as both a songwriter and a person, definitely has. He says now, that he would rather forget most of the first album and also maintains that he thought Blooddrunk was a very good album. That's his taste, and maybe it wasn't ten years ago, or maybe it's not so much yours or mine today - but, again, he's still a person. Maybe he's made some mistakes, maybe he's written some weak songs, maybe he's grown up a little bit from his days of dog collars and teenage mind. Whatever has happened, I think it's good as long as he's happy with himself, his life. And same thing to everyone in the band; Henkka, Roope, Jaska, Janne.
I think I would stop listening to COB, or any band, if they intentionally changed their sound to match mainstream, or intentionally "went back" to their earlier sound. Either direction is, to me, giving up one's self up as an artist. I just want some soul in my music! Hahah.
((This post is not really directed at anyone in particular, it's just my take on the whole thing.))
...Now, as for OMGOMGCOB fans, as well as OMGOMGALEXI fans - well, I can say to them, "Fuck you!"