From your posts, I see you and I are paying attention to different aspects of mixing and mastering. Which is not surprising, seeing as there aren't quite too many metalhead audiophiles out there
a muddy sound (+ crappy guitar tone?) almost as if they tried to acquire something by placing the importance of heavy elements on top of lead elements. The echo in the drums is quite long too.
This may also be due to the band's new musical attitude, which implies a heavier and less melodic sound. Muddier guitars and less prominent keyboards, together with solos that are less in the foreground, make the record sound heavier, thrashier and maybe a tad more nu-metalish. I remember reading a review for either AYDY or BD in which the reviewer wondered whether Janne was still in the band (so much for less prominent keyboards).
when you play the intro of Towards Dead End. I think it's screaming for more bass and heaviness for drums, especially as the guitar tone is clear like a dentist's drill
Yep, HB's recording was definitely kind of... dry. It could have used a slightly warmer sound with more bass.
HCD's for me COB at it's best as far as sound is concerned
I'd have to agree, albeit partly. Doubled guitars were a blessing to that record, though it still could have used a less boomy bass sound and a higher dynamic range (I can't recall the exact figure, but it wasn't too far from AYDY's and BD's, around 5db). That's why I asked about Matt Hydes policy on the loudness war. Avoiding the
Death Magnetic effect is what I consider the very least any band could do for their records; but that doesn't necessarily mean the records won't be compressed. Quite the contrary. Modern CDs are (almost) all heavily compressed, which makes them that much less enjoyable for me. I'm not asking for otherworldly dynamic range figures, but around 10db would be pretty decent (e.g. one of my favorite Threat Signal songs,
Counterbalance, has a dynamic range of 9db and it still sounds pretty loud and powerful - I don't see why the same can't be done for any other metal band).
in BD guitars and keys were a bit too sharp. Get the keys a bit more body, the guitars maybe a bit less treble and I think it's good to go. If I'm to choose an already existing tone, T,L&S tone is to me the best COB has had.
Once again, I'd have to agree with you.
but IMO Knuckleduster is the best tone I have ever heard from them.
Also one of the best songs, imho.