Whats wrong with the production?
Maybe I don't listen to enough similar artists, but the desired "overall sound" is all over the place. It's like the band wanted it to sound one way (warm 70's guitar tones), and the mix engineer was still coming off his cocaine binge from the 80's (Horrible, vaguely digital-sounding, trebly nonsense). None of the instruments (especially the vocals) seem to fit nicely (in terms of the "space" they occupy) in the mix... I dunno, it just overall doesn't sound right at all.
Also it's mixed SO QUIETLY. In a bad way, not an anti-loudness-wars way.
It basically just doesn't POP, it doesn't sound exciting... It sounds very middle-of-the road and stays that way for most of the album. As much as I really wanna get excited I find myself going "eh..."
Edit: What I mean by this, I guess, is I always want it to jump into that "FUCK YEAH I'M SO PUMPED UP!" territory, and something about it always falls short of that. Like the chorus for Stand By Him should sound a lot more bombastic, just as the actual parts are written... But the mix engineer prettttyy much ignored that and kept the whole thing at the same pace rather than moving along with the music.
Not to say Ritual and Stand by Him, etc aren't awesome and catchy tracks... It just could have been treated better and become a MUCH stronger album.