Ermz
¯\(°_o)/¯
I dunno.. I think you have cleaner transients without going into a desk.. but you have FATTER and more MUSICAL transients with the console.
I'd agree with that.
IMO that effect is desirable in a great majority of music. It just so happens that certain genres of metal are in the tiny exception zone. What some guys here might find as a shock - especially if they're going for super clean mixes for tech death, thrash, whatever, is that those fatter transients just result in mud at high tempos.
@Lucas: You sure you guys aren't hearing harsh aliasing as high-end clarity? I had a similar effect tracking guitars here. I use TSE 808 and 8505 at generally low quality settings. Then when I throw supersampling on for the bounce I find that it all gets much smoother (like the real-life equivalents) and I have to dime some highs back in.