Your Top 5 Albums (by bands you've heard 5 albums from)

God Dethroned:
1) Into the Lungs of Hell
2) Under the Sign of the Iron Cross
3) The Grand Grimore
4) The Toxic Touch
5) Passiondale

Deicide:
1) Legion
2) Deicide
3) Serpents of the Light
4) Once Upon the Cross
5) To Hell With God

Megadeth:
1) Rust in Peace
2) Peace Sells
3) United Abominations
4) Countdown to Extinction
5) The System Has Failed

Amon Amarth:
1) Fate of Norns
2) Versus the World
3) Twilight of the Thundergod
4) With Oden on Our Side
5) Avenger

Bal-Sagoth:
1) The Power Cosmic
2) Atlantis Ascendant
3) Battle Magic
4) Starfire Burning Upon the Ice Veiled Throne of Ultima Thule
5) The Chthonic Chronicles
 
Pink Floyd:

1. Wish You Were Here
2. Dark Side of the Moon
3. Animals
4. Meddle
5. More

King Crimson

1. In the Court of the Crimson King
2. Red
3. Discipline
4. Islands
5. Larks Toungues in Aspic

Led Zeppelin

1. I
2. Houses of the Holy
3. IV
4. Physical Graffiti (First disc is the best thing Zep ever made, but the second disc has a lot of filler).
5. II

My Dying Bride

1. Angel and the Dark River
2. Turn Loose the Swans
3. The Dreaful Hours
4. As the Flower Withers
5. The Light at the End of the World

Drudkh

1. Autum Aurora
2. Blood in Our Wells
3. Forgotten Legends
4. Microcosmos
5. Songs of Grief and Solitude
 
Morbid Angel:
1. Altars of Madness
2. Formulas Fatal to the Flesh
3. Blessed Are the Sick
4. Covenant
5. Illud Divinum Insanus

Megadeth:
1. Rust In Peace
2. Peace Sells
3. Killing Is My Business...
4. Countdown to Extinction
5. So Far So Good...

Metallica:
1. ...And Justice For All
2. Kill Em All
3. Master of Puppets
4. Ride the Lightning
5. Death Magnetic

Darkthrone:
1. De Mysteriis Dom Sathanas
2. Deathcrush
3. Ordo Ad Chao
4. Wolf's Lair Abyss
5. Grand Declaration of War

Darkthrone:
1. Transilvanian Hunger
2. Soulside Journey
3. A Blaze In the Northern Sky
4. Under A Funeral Moon
5. Panzerfaust

Fear Factory:
1. Demanufacture
2. Soul of a New Machine
3. Remanufacture
4. Mechanize (Gene Hoglan is a monster)
5. Obsolete

Burzum:
1. Filosofem
2. Hvis lyset tar oss
3. Dauði Baldrs
4. Burzum
5. Hliðskjálf

Sepultura
1. Beneath the Remains
2. Schizophrenia
3. Morbid Visions
4. Arise
5. Bestial Devastation

Cryptopsy
1. None So Vile
2. Blasphemy Made Flesh
3. Once Was Not
4. Cryptopsy
5. Whisper Supremacy

Pantera:
1. The Great Southern Trendkill
2. Far Beyond Driven
3. Cowboys From Hell
4. Vulgar Display of Power
5. Reinventing the Steel
 
So crimsonfloyd, when I list this shit for you, should I include significant EPs/Demos/Comps? Cuz that determines if Slayer, Beherit, etc. even make the cut for 5 worthy releases.
 
I should clarify one thing for all of you who are currently down on me and my opinions regarding words like "worthy". I am not trying to be elitest here, but rather, I simply have higher standards than most today for my music in that I would much rather have a few albums with intimate connections than a shit-ton of albums that are merely "cool" or "kickass" or "br00tal". I have heard tens of thousands of metal songs, like most of you, but my current collection only has about 4000 songs in the metal genre. I tend to see a larger collection as a roadblock to developing intimate connections with the best of the genre. So, a reminder to you all: "unworthy" is not synonymous with "sounds bad" but rather signifies that an album is simply unworthy of devoting dozens of listens to for the sake of a deeper meaning.
 
Here's what I can think of right now. Bands with 5 worthy FULL-LENGTHS only.

Bathory
1. Blood Fire Death
2. Under The Sign Of The Black Mark
3. The Return......
4. Bathory
5. Hammerheart

Black Sabbath
1. Vol. 4
2. Master Of Reality
3. Black Sabbath
4. Paranoid
5. Heaven & Hell

Burzum
1. Hvis Lyset Tar Oss
2. Filosofem
3. Burzum
4. Det Som En Gang Var
5. Hliðskjálf

Darkthrone
1. Under A Funeral Moon
2. A Blaze In The Northern Sky
3. Soulside Journey
4. Panzerfaust
5. Transilvanian Hunger

Summoning
1. Dol Guldur
2. Minas Morgul
3. Oath Bound
4. Stronghold
5. Old Mornings Dawn

Those five definitely make it. Coroner's 5 albums are all good and they should make it, but I'm not sure how to order them right now. As for Graveland, their inclusion would depend on me deciding on the worthiness of Following The Voice Of Blood, but I definitely love 4 of their albums besides that. Slayer ofc has one of the best runs in history but I'm not a big fan of Seasons so I'd probably only be able to honestly include them with Haunting The Chapel. Oh and Immolation/Manilla Roadsurely have 5 masterful albums in their styles, but their middle-grade albums tend to wear on me towards the end, so they'd only make it on a good day ;)

Oh, and if I find another worthy Voivod album after Nothingface, I suppose they could make it.
 
5 - need to listen to Forumlas and Gateways again to make up my mind

Formulas is superior. The lyrics are something else too..really special.

"The gift of flesh
Was in fact life's curse
Although born one in the same
In Spirit, but the flesh all too coarse"

Trey's solos are really beautiful and abstract. Based off of interviews I've read, he's very spiritual when it comes to his playing, like Steve Vai. He goes into hallucinogenic places without the use of drugs. The guy is a genius.



Pete recorded some next level shit drum tracks for the time. Even by the standards of today, the drumming is pretty insane. Steve Tucker's performance is solid for his first album with them. I don't mind his vocals. They're a bit generic. I prefer Vincent's from Altars to Covenant. He is definitely a good bass player, though. Technically speaking, it's MA's most complex.


Heavy seven string sludge riff-age.


Starts very fast and brutal and ends very beautifully.


Classic Morbid Angel. Aggressive and fast.


Overall, 10/10 classic album. Underrated as fuck.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
The Teutonic trio...

Destruction: (if you include any of their post-Cracked Brain albums after having heard all those previous, you fail, sorry)
Eternal Devastation
Cracked Brain
Sentence of Death
Release from Agony
Infernal Overkill

Kreator:
Pleasure to Kill
Endless Pain
Renewal
Cause for Conflict
Extreme Aggression* (I used to hate this one, but a recent listen was like a completely different album so this could go higher or disappear again in the future)

Sodom:
In the Sign of Evil
M-16
Obsessed By Cruelty
Tapping the Vein
Persecution Mania
 
Pretty much their worst album, even if some of their 90's punk-oriented stuff is a little less listenable. Whenever some black metal listening wimp goes on about thrash's inherent lack of creative breadth or whatever, you know it's because he got to Agent Orange and Arise and stopped digging there.
 
Really? That's easily my favourite of theirs - it's got such great production, very tight musically, and has one of their best riff sections in "Tired and Red".

I was gonna say Extreme Aggression is my favourite Kreator album too - obviously different tastes!
 
Also

Kyuss

1. and The Circus Leaves Town
2. Blues for the Red Sun
3. Welcome to Sky Valley
4. Wretch
5. Muchas Gracias: The Best of Kyuss
 
Judas Priest:
1) Stained Glass
2) Painkiller
3) Screaming for Vengeance
4) Sad Wings of Destiny
5) British Steel

Saxon:
1) Strong Arm of the Law
2) Wheels of Steel
3) Crusader
4) Sacrifice
5) Call to Arms

Iron Maiden:
1) Piece of Mind
2) Seventh Son of a Seventh Son
3) Powerslave
4) Iron Maiden
5) Number of the Beast

Accept:
1) Balls to the Wall
2) Restless and Wild
3) Metalheart
4) Stalingrad
5) Blood of the Nations

Children of Bodom:
1) Hatebreeder
2) Follow the Reaper
3) Hate Crew Deathroll
4) Relentless, Reckless Forever
5) Are You Dead Yet